furia furialog · New Particles · The War Against Silence · Aedliga (songs) · photography · code · other things     ↑vF
2000 Pazz & Jop critical alignment ratings
Here are the voters in the 2000 Village Voice Pazz & Jop Critics' Poll, ranked according to the average number of other voters who voted for each of their album picks, singles picks, or both together. If anyone had voted for the exact ten album winners, their album rating would have been 112.1; for the exact ten singles, their singles rating would have been 80.1; for all twenty, their combined rating would have been 96.1. Higher ratings are possible for partial ballots, although for the purposes of these charts I disqualified anybody with fewer than five votes in either category, or fewer than eight total. The minimum rating, of course, for an entirely unique ballot, is 0. Click the headings to see the voters ranked that way. I come in pretty far down no matter how you look at it.
ranked by albums ratings
rank albums singles combined voter
1105.9 105.9Letta Tayler
296.769.883.3Michael Gallucci
395.959.277.6Max Berry
495.3 95.3Toure Toure
594.521.558.0Roger Catlin
693.3 93.3Patricia Grandjean
791.228.059.6Robert Hilburn
888.430.859.6Julie Taraska
987.435.061.2Tom Moon
1086.513.750.1Ed Condran
1186.147.967.0Jason Fine
1286.044.565.3Alan Light
1385.552.368.9Christopher O'Connor
1484.444.664.5L. Kent Wolgamott
1583.743.563.6Ken Capobianco
1683.726.650.1Rodd McLeod
1782.951.067.0Michael Jarrett
1881.121.051.1Alec Foege
1980.632.656.6John McPartlin
2080.044.062.0Corey du Browa
2180.014.547.3Al Choman
2279.8 79.8Jon Pareles
2379.122.951.0Timothy Finn
2478.248.463.3Chris Norris
2578.150.764.4Werner Trieschmann
2678.023.250.6Brian Howard
2777.9 77.9Joe Heim
2877.826.252.0Gary Chun
2977.6 77.6Steve Bodow
3077.5 77.5Sacha Jenkins
3176.644.760.7Steve Kiviat
3276.237.656.9Richard Abowitz
3375.958.067.0Ken Tucker
3475.738.056.9Sia Michel
3575.736.055.9M. Tye Comer
3675.334.554.9Craig Marks
3774.847.761.3Roy Trakin
3874.628.951.8Melissa Ruggieri
3974.252.863.5Dan DeLuca
4072.7 7.5Tom Smucker
4171.515.343.4Amy Phillips
4270.927.049.0Dimitry Elias Leger
4370.339.755.0Anthony Bozza
4470.313.013.1Phillip Overeem
4570.052.561.3Ivan Kreilkamp
4669.642.556.1Matt Conaway
4769.633.251.4Jim Connelly
4869.467.268.7Gina Vivinetto
4969.345.458.0Greg Kot
5069.118.944.0Miles Marshall Lewis
5169.054.962.0Bill Friskics-Warren
5268.6 68.6Mark Schone
5367.5 67.5Kevin O'Hare
5467.458.864.5Carola Dibbell
5567.346.156.7James Sullivan
5667.2 49.2Chris Parker
5766.836.851.8Glenn Gamboa
5866.650.960.1Jeff Jackson
5966.537.051.8Raqiyah Mays
6066.014.640.3Cyndi Elliot
6165.8 65.8Rob Brunner
6265.5 65.5John Bitzer
6365.432.351.8Keith Phipps
6465.1 65.1David Menconi
6564.417.844.1Mark Mangold
6664.1 64.1Austin Scaggs
6763.537.050.3Charles Aaron
6863.536.049.8Daniel Durchholz
6963.0 63.0John Fortunato
7062.686.870.7Barry M. Prickett
7162.641.352.0Alex Pappademas
7262.517.339.9Tim Grierson
7362.328.545.4Dan Hooley
7462.1 62.1Thor Christensen
7561.933.347.6Paul Robicheau
7661.8 61.8Ann Powers
7761.852.557.2Will Hermes
7861.827.644.7Todd Kristel
7961.746.254.0Gary Graff
8061.441.054.6Nathan Brackett
8161.346.854.1Robert Christgau
8260.912.936.9Milo Miles
8360.7 60.7Ken Micallef
8460.629.545.1Jazzbo/Joseph Patel
8560.439.449.9Alec Hanley Bemis
8660.332.646.5Joshua Klein
8760.030.245.1Greg Glasgow
8859.734.347.0Tom Lane
8959.715.037.4Erik Pedersen
9059.5 59.5Jon Matsumoto
9159.4 59.4Keith Moerer
9259.414.837.1Jody Rosen
9359.153.156.1Joe Gross
9459.138.548.8Havelock Nelson
9559.010.033.2Bonso Thompson
9658.941.350.1Laura DeMarco
9758.838.648.7Selwyn Hinds
9858.85.232.0Steve Klinge
9958.7 58.7Neil Strauss
10058.5 58.5dream hampton
10158.415.436.9Karla Peterson
10258.3 58.3Dave Bry
10358.225.441.8Joshua Leeman
10458.218.838.5Andrea Duncan
10558.125.341.7Margeaux Watson
10657.624.641.1Rhonda Baraka
10757.529.443.5Steve Dollar
10857.436.846.6George Varga
10957.278.464.3Michael Corcoran
11057.227.342.3Jon Wiederhorn
11157.215.536.4Jane Dark
11256.816.735.7Chris Riemenschneider
11356.733.144.9Nelson George
11456.435.644.8Rob Marriott
11556.424.540.5Ethan Brown
11656.232.444.3Peter Scholtes
11756.1 56.1Scott Floman
11856.130.543.3Hobey Echlin
11956.129.542.8Joe Levy
12056.0 56.0Rick de Yampert
12155.953.854.9Bob Grossweiner
12255.935.545.7Shaheem Reid
12355.928.042.0Philip Martin
12455.338.146.7Franklin Soults
12555.231.743.5Scott Henkemeyer
12655.047.551.3Josh duLac
12754.937.746.3Gabriel Alvarez
12854.8 54.8Rick Reger
12954.825.840.3Jessica Winter
13054.819.737.3Jaime Lowe
13154.4 54.4Steve Matteo
13254.333.043.7Sheena Lester
13354.310.632.5Steve Erickson
13453.926.839.6Smith Galtney
13553.852.052.9Anthony DeCurtis
13653.523.038.3Beth Massa
13753.457.655.5Lee Gardner
13853.426.439.9Elizabeth Mendez Berry
13952.832.742.8Matt Ashare
14052.513.533.0Dave Tompkins
14152.42.727.6Nana Brew-Hammond
14252.322.537.4Chris Sealy
14352.220.936.6Randall Grass
14452.031.241.6David Fricke
14551.930.541.2Trent Fitzgerald
14651.733.242.5J. Anthony Ware
14751.529.940.7Rob Michaels
14851.513.232.4Oliver Wang
14951.422.537.0Sasha Frere-Jones
15051.224.537.9Nathan Rabin
15151.224.437.8Rob Tannenbaum
15251.218.835.0Jon Caramanica
15351.0 51.0Rob Kenner
15450.727.539.1Alex Ross
15550.722.836.8Hobart Rowland
15650.662.854.7Jem Aswad
15750.652.751.7Kembrew McLeod
15850.5 50.5Jeff Salamon
15950.4 50.4Jennifer Vineyard
16050.433.842.1Todd S. Inoue
16150.431.040.7Corey Moss
16250.43.927.2Barry Walters
16350.322.336.3Elliott Wilson
16450.255.852.1Stephanie Zacharek
16550.1 50.1Dominic Salerno
16650.122.436.3Sonia Murray
16750.119.034.6Rob Kemp
16849.841.846.0Jon Bream
16949.7 49.7Jim Macnie
17049.730.740.2Keith Harris
17149.626.237.9Sarah Rodman
17249.149.149.1Jason Ferguson
17349.134.541.8Bret McCabe
17449.19.029.1K. Sanneh
17549.0 49.0Richard Cromelin
17649.022.817.8Chris Cook
17748.9 48.9Sara Manaugh
17848.715.632.2Jeff "Chairman" Mao
17948.6 48.6David Jarman
18048.6 48.6Tyler Kord
18148.518.133.3Marianne Meyer
18248.225.737.0Chris Willman
18348.225.636.9Carey Price
18448.121.034.6Ken Rayes
18548.033.641.6JoE Silva
18648.034.341.2Amy Linden
18747.943.954.2Steve Knopper
18847.750.249.0Cary Darling
18947.7 47.7Erik Davis
19047.6 47.6Mark Binelli
19147.66.627.1Lissa Townsend Rodgers
19247.550.048.8Dave Lindquist
19347.48.326.8David Sprague
19447.329.538.4David Simutis
19547.055.951.5Stephen Deusner
19646.936.341.6Rod Pocowatchit
19746.915.331.1John Serba
19846.7 46.7Jenny Eliscu
19946.637.442.0Ted Friedman
20046.516.131.3Stephen Thompson
20146.324.635.5Joshua Goldfein
20246.1 46.1Greg Siegel
20346.141.543.8Randall Roberts
20445.840.943.4Judith Kaufman
20545.835.840.8Lang Thompson
20645.728.737.2Richard Martin
20745.716.130.9Raquel Cepeda
20845.614.430.0Britt Robson
20945.68.627.1Eddie Houghton
21045.553.949.7Tony Green
21145.112.828.1Colin Devenish
21244.644.658.7Chris Herrington
21344.328.236.7Steve Hochman
21444.2 44.2Robert Wilonsky
21544.126.535.3J.D. Considine
21643.817.030.4Sylvia Chan
21743.7 50.1P. Gregory Springer
21843.728.636.2Kem Poston
21943.1 43.1John Milward
22043.07.025.0Craig Smith
22142.829.436.1Bill Crandall
22242.651.947.5Roni Sarig
22342.635.138.9Howard Cohen
22442.5 42.5Allen Czelusniak
22542.432.637.5Mac Randall
22642.3 42.3Charlie Braxton
22742.3 42.3Kelvin Williams
22842.148.745.4Tom Sinclair
22942.118.530.3Jerry Dannemiller
23042.112.027.1Hua Hsu
23142.0 42.0Eric Demby
23242.037.839.9Vince Aletti
23342.037.539.8Kevin Devine
23442.013.227.6Rachel Leibrock
23542.07.124.6Alexandra Phanor
23641.754.248.0Shane Harrison
23741.617.929.1Kuri Kondrak
23841.419.230.3Charles R. Cross
23940.91.921.4Curtis Schieber
24040.79.124.9Chuck Eddy
24140.610.225.4Bill Holdship
24240.542.343.5Scott Woods
24340.5 40.5Brett Sokol
24440.043.441.7Frank Williams
24539.822.233.9Lydia Vanderloo
24639.825.833.6Chris Nelson
24739.6 39.6William Van Meter
24839.616.227.9Fred M. Mills
24939.5 39.5Robin A. Rothman
25039.451.545.5Rob Sheffield
25139.4 39.4Peter Margasak
25239.415.227.3Jackie McCarthy
25339.240.539.9Gavin Edwards
25439.2 39.2Jay Ruttenberg
25539.218.628.4Carrie Havranek
25639.013.826.4David Wild
25738.911.325.1Simon Reynolds
25838.7 38.7Jonathan Valania
25938.715.227.0Erin Anderson
26038.426.732.6Phil Gallo
26138.2 38.2Vaughn Watson
26238.219.929.1Bud Scoppa
26337.8 37.8Rickey Vincent
26437.733.435.6Soren Baker
26537.6 37.6Neil Gladstone
26637.314.025.7Dara Cook
26737.116.626.9Michael A. Goldberg
26836.837.837.3Renee Graham
26936.8 36.8Richard C. Walls
27036.6 36.6Carlton Wade
27136.613.525.1Jon Jon Scott
27236.5 36.5Allen St. John
27336.40.218.3Stephen W. Terrell
27436.332.134.2Ron Hart
27536.328.532.4Steve Pick
27636.0 36.0Greg Casseus
27736.0 36.0Holly George-Warren
27835.8 35.8Steve Stolder
27935.716.125.9Andi Zeisler
28035.6 34.4Steve Horowitz
28135.615.225.4John Walker
28235.312.924.1Randy Silver
28335.224.129.7Michael Goldberg
28435.114.925.0Andy Greenwald
28535.026.330.7Pete Glowatsky
28634.915.125.0Kevin John
28734.8 34.8Gaylord Fields
28834.7 34.7Buzz Morison
28934.639.036.8Rickey Wright
29034.457.946.2Jon Dolan
29134.317.425.9David J. Prince
29234.29.521.9Craig Seymour
29334.114.224.2Sam Cannon
29433.8 33.8Laura Morgan
29533.17.020.1Kris Chen
29633.031.632.3Michael Lach
29733.01.517.3George Yatchisin
29832.87.520.2Nick Tangborn
29932.721.026.9Elysa Gardner
30032.56.119.3Jeff Chang
30132.425.729.1Jim Farber
30232.2 32.2Andrew Nash
30332.1 35.6Tim Midget
30432.0 32.0Steve Morse
30532.0 32.0Chris Ryan
30631.913.722.8Andrew Miller
30731.842.737.3David Browne
30831.7 31.7Sal Caputo
30931.7 31.7Arnold Pan
31031.4 20.3Jerome Annum
31131.2 31.2Scott Frampton
31231.22.116.7Neil Drumming
31331.122.827.0Michael Paoletta
31430.68.619.6Matthew Cooke
31530.3 30.3Noel Murray
31630.133.131.6John Elsasser
31730.1 30.1Jeff Stratton
31829.939.834.9G. Brown
31929.924.227.1Patricia Deluca
32029.876.445.3Ezra Feinberg
32129.80.915.4Kevin Cole
32229.618.424.0Shirley Halperin
32329.537.033.3Eric Broome
32429.53.716.6Aliya King
32529.319.724.5Ed Masley
32629.047.238.1Michaelangelo Matos
32729.01.415.2Glen Dixon
32828.8 28.8Michael Azerrad
32928.641.835.2Mike Rubin
33028.6 28.6Ken Richardson
33128.6 28.6Randy Lewis
33228.626.627.6Fred Shuster
33328.60.714.7Eric T. Miller
33428.514.422.7Marina Zogbi
33528.4 28.4Bob Gulla
33628.410.719.6Peter Terzian
33728.29.618.9Mike McGonigal
33828.134.431.3Richard Torres
33928.1 28.1Jeremy Tepper
34028.125.426.8A.D. Amorosi
34128.0 28.0Lloyd Sachs
34227.832.430.1Connie Johnson
34327.8 27.8Seth Mnookin
34427.7 27.7Don McLeese
34527.719.323.5Eric Weisbard
34627.628.127.9Franklin Paul
34727.618.723.2Holly Gleason
34827.617.822.7Kandia Crazy Horse
34927.411.321.4Carlo Wolff
35027.325.026.2Leigh-Ann Jackson
35127.311.419.4Chuck Campbell
35226.9 26.9Jim Testa
35326.722.524.5Jim Walsh
35426.73.815.3Martin Johnson
35526.72.114.4Stacy Osbaum
35626.6 26.6David Shirley
35726.4 26.4Tom Cheyney
35826.420.323.4Darrell M. McNeill
35926.335.430.9Tom Laskin
36026.229.938.9Tricia Romano
36126.2 26.2Lisa Gidley
36225.9 25.9Michael Loverude
36325.9 25.9Kris Ex
36425.817.921.9Patrick Berkery
36525.612.620.2Mara Schwartz
36625.41.013.2Jonathan Perry
36725.3 25.3Anastasia Pantsios
36825.2 25.2Carla DeSantis
36925.151.834.0Brent Burton
37024.928.726.9Soo-Hyun Chung
37124.821.823.3James Hannaham
37224.7  Camden Joy
37324.427.025.7Geoffrey Himes
37424.413.018.7Stacy Gueresava
37524.412.918.7James Hunter
37624.320.822.6Mike Mettler
37724.313.418.9Daniel Chamberlin
37824.34.314.3Jason Cohen
37924.30.312.3Thomas May
38024.231.928.1Ken Barnes
38124.230.727.5Jennifer Schwartz
38224.139.830.0Greg Tate
38324.132.228.2Peter Shapiro
38424.0 30.3Cheryl Botchick
38524.05.714.9Nick Catucci
38623.8 23.8Don Share
38723.655.039.3Greg Beets
38823.626.325.0Jeremy Helligar
38923.338.831.1Dev Sherlock
39023.011.817.4Mark Jenkins
39122.7 22.7John Chandler
39222.62.412.5Andrew Bartlett
39322.3 22.3Kenny Berkowitz
39422.3 22.3Lauren Viera
39522.317.119.4Vanessa Satten
39622.13.712.9J. Eric Smith
39722.025.323.7Alex Henderson
39821.9 21.9Dan Ouellette
39921.924.723.3Chris Junior
40021.80.111.0Karen Iris Tucker
40121.6 21.6Larry King
40221.5 21.5Carle VP Groome
40321.532.927.2Matt Hendrickson
40421.526.223.9Sly Stallone
40521.4 21.4Steven Ward
40621.426.524.0Richard Skanse
40721.43.612.5Don Kaye
40821.33.215.3Steve Ciabattoni
40920.739.429.6Parke Puterbaugh
41020.410.115.3Sara Sherr
41120.111.715.9Enrique Lavin
41219.9 19.9Jim DeRogatis
41319.918.119.0Scott Schinder
41419.8 19.8Bill Ellis
41519.825.621.7John Soeder
41619.02.712.3Bridget Burns
41718.9 18.9Wayne Bledsoe
41818.83.710.4Mykella Van Cooten
41918.727.423.1Michael D. Clark
42018.530.724.6Steve Reynolds
42118.3 18.3Tim Riley
42218.313.415.7Tony Tranfa
42318.2 18.2Fred Cisterna
42418.10.29.2Diego Hadis
42518.0 18.0Mitch Myers
42617.95.011.5Kok Kian Goh
42717.731.224.5Dennis Lim
42817.30.58.9Douglas Wolk
42917.113.115.2Steve Rosen
43017.112.214.7Kara Manning
43117.023.920.5Tony Fletcher
43216.8 16.8Matthew Fritch
43316.6 16.6Roy Kasten
43416.335.324.7Marc Weingarten
43516.223.319.8Andrew Dansby
43616.117.416.8Billy Altman
43715.82.18.6Bobby Tanzilo
43815.7 15.7Katherine Spielmann
43915.5 15.5Tad Hendrickson
44015.520.317.9Elisabeth Vincentelli
44115.50.98.2Lois Maffeo
44215.411.713.6Josh Kun
44315.11.98.5Meredith Ochs
44415.0 15.0Matt Ryan
44514.6 14.6Anders Smith Lindall
44614.667.633.5Jon Fine
44714.5 14.5David Krasnow
44814.3 14.3Jeff Tamarkin
44914.1 14.1Steven Stancell
45014.030.122.1Frank Kogan
45113.81.17.8Linda Ray
45213.74.49.1Kurt B. Reighley
45313.69.411.5Don Allred
45413.316.715.0Michael Curtin
45513.2 13.2Brian Cullman
45613.11.21.3John Wojtowicz
45712.918.815.5Andrew Monko
45812.7 12.7Lorne Behrman
45912.40.76.6Marc Gilman
46012.324.518.4Carly Carioli
46112.34.88.9William Ruhlmann
46212.24.98.6Rick Mitchell
46312.1 12.1Michael Lipton
46412.02.87.4Chris Baty
46511.94.18.0Serena Kim
46611.7 11.7Rich Kane
46711.62.26.9David Lawrence Dunlap Jr.
46811.3 11.3Lisa Garrett
46911.24.57.9Erik Himmelsbach
47011.114.612.9Pat Pierson
47111.11.05.8Josh Norek
47211.0 11.0Ben Ratliff
47311.0 11.0Steve Graybow
47411.020.515.8Jason Gross
47511.00.96.0Dylan Siegler
47610.89.710.3Robert Nedelkoff
47710.81.56.2Peter Blackstock
47810.7 10.7Grant Alden
47910.333.722.0Ira Robbins
48010.2 10.2Rich Masio
4819.8 9.8Will Romano
4829.80.35.1J Neo Marvin
4839.7 9.7Dave DiMartino
4849.71.26.9David Jackson
4859.6 9.6Pamela Murray Winters
4869.4 9.4D. Strauss
4879.4 9.4Marc Greilsamer
4889.3 9.3Jason Verlinde
4899.23.96.6Leland Rucker
4909.0 9.0Steve Connell
4919.01.05.0Kim Cooper
4928.94.67.5Sandy Masuo
4938.80.84.8Michael Krugman
4948.7 8.7Ed Morales
4958.6 8.6Bart Becker
4968.62.05.3Gail O'Hara
4978.4 8.4Kim Taylor
4988.3 8.3Jay Orr
4998.311.29.8Dan Aloi
5008.31.95.1Adrianna Lopez
5018.0 8.0Bill Meyer
5027.9 7.9Steve Simels
5037.912.210.1Bob Ruggiero
5047.80.24.0Dan Strachota
5057.6 7.6Janiss Garza
5067.6 7.6Joe Harrington
5077.541.834.0Scott Seward
5087.415.711.6Mosi Reeves
5097.3 7.3Jon Young
5107.12.64.9Judson Kilpatrick
5117.043.219.1Matt Hickey
5126.9 6.9Kay Bourne
5136.511.38.9Dan Epstein
5146.1 6.1Michael Freedberg
5156.126.816.5John Butland
5166.0 6.0David M. Snyder
5176.0 6.0Abraham Velez
5185.90.13.0Jud Cost
5195.60.22.9Hillary Chute
5205.2 5.2Jim Catalano
5215.07.76.4Marc Weisblott
5225.02.44.1Bill Holmes
5234.60.32.5Jack Rabid
5244.2 4.2Spence D.
5254.1 4.1Rob O'Connor
5264.1 4.1Steve Duda
5274.1 4.1Peter Davis
5284.16.55.3Steve Bloom
5294.11.72.9Eric Bensel
5304.0 3.8J Poet
5314.01.42.7Joshua Feigelman
5323.8 3.8Glenn Donaldson
5333.70.11.6Banning Eyre
5343.48.36.0Amy Sciarretto
5353.2 3.2Kevin R. Convey
5363.2 3.2Chris Nickson
5373.0 3.0Bill Milkowski
5383.0 3.0Lawrence Kay
5392.9 2.9Fred Kaplan
5402.94.43.4J. R. Taylor
5412.92.62.8Gail Worley
5422.8 2.8George Petros
5432.85.44.5Mike Saunders
5442.6 2.6Marty Lipp
5452.4 2.4Ian Christe
5462.47.24.8Jill Blardinelli
5472.13.72.9Jim Meyer
5482.10.21.2J.R. Jones
5491.91.51.7Paul Semel
5501.8 1.8Larry Birnbaum
5511.70.10.9Adam McGovern
5521.70.00.9Heath Hignight
5531.612.06.8Eugene Holley Jr
5541.5 1.5Greg Burk
5551.512.47.0Jim Bessman
5561.442.245.6Laura Sinagra
5571.40.30.8Tim Haslett
5581.3 1.3Richard Gehr
5591.2 1.2Scott Isler
5601.2 1.2Darren Ressler
5611.19.95.5glenn mcdonald
5621.0 1.0PJ Gach
5631.030.810.9David Adler
5640.91.11.0Andrew Scott Earles
5650.810.76.0Falling James
5660.7 1.0Arsenio Orteza
5670.7 0.7Deena Dasein
5680.5 0.5Damon Krukowski
5690.4 0.4Paul-Emile Comeau
5700.4 0.4Robin Edgerton
5710.2 0.2Ken Roseman
5720.2 0.2Jordan Mamone
5730.2 0.2Stacy Meyn
5740.2 0.2Michael Stone
5750.2 0.2Tim Ellison
5760.20.20.2Dawn Eden
5770.20.00.1George Smith
5780.20.00.1P. Edwin Letcher
5790.1 0.1David Wondrich
5800.12.41.2Liz Armstrong
5810.0  Andrew Palmer
Site contents published by glenn mcdonald under a Creative Commons BY/NC/ND License except where otherwise noted.