furia furialog · New Particles · The War Against Silence · Aedliga (songs) · photography · code · other things     ↑vF
2002 Pazz & Jop critical alignment ratings
Here are the voters in the 2002 Village Voice Pazz & Jop Critics' Poll, ranked according to the average number of other voters who voted for each of their album picks. If anyone had voted for the exact ten 2002 album winners, their rating would have been 112.8 (compared to 105.8 in 2001 and 112.1 in 2000), suggesting that last year's list might have represented a slightly weaker consensus, or a slightly less egregious collective failure of imagination, depending on your perspective. Once again, my own opinions are unpopular.
rank rating voter
1103.9Ed Condran
291.6Stephen Mooallem
391.1Scott Floman
489.8Stephen M. Deusner
589.6Isaac Guzman
689.0Michael Gallucci
788.8Keith Phipps
888.0Tom Moon
987.5Robert Hilburn
1087.2Christopher O'Connor
1187.1Jon Wiederhorn
1286.2Neva Chonin
1385.8Dave Lipp
1485.3Ken Rayes
1584.3Joe D'Angelo
1683.9Mac Randall
1782.0Gavin Edwards
1881.3Mark Zepezauer
1980.9Alan Light
2078.3Ben Wener
2178.2Patricia Grandjean
2277.9Jim Tremayne
2377.1Gary Chun
2476.8Paul Robicheau
2576.5Steve Appleford
2675.9Allen St. John
2775.9Max Berry
2874.7Al Choman
2974.2Chris Baldwin
3074.0Nathan Brackett
3173.8Steve Klinge
3273.7Carrie Havranek
3373.5RJ Smith
3473.0Alec Foege
3572.8Roy Kasten
3672.3Corey du Browa
3772.3Tracy Pepper
3871.6Joe Hagan
3971.5Jonathan Valania
4071.5Nicole Keiper
4171.3Julie Taraska
4271.2Joshua Klein
4370.7David Fricke
4470.5Richard Abowitz
4570.1Nick Marino
4669.6Phil Gallo
4768.8Richard Cromelin
4868.3Jeff Stratton
4968.3Jeff Jackson
5068.3L. Kent Wolgamott
5168.1Sara Manaugh
5267.4Jason Fine
5367.1Thee-O
5466.7Chris Norris
5566.4Evelyn McDonnell
5665.8David Wild
5765.6Jim DeRogatis
5865.3Michael Lach
5965.1Steve Simels
6064.9Alex Pappademas
6164.9Chris Nelson
6264.7Will Hermes
6364.4Jon Matsumoto
6464.2Jessica Hundley
6564.2Rob Brunner
6664.1Steve Knopper
6763.7Philip Martin
6863.4Parke Puterbaugh
6963.3Nate Patrin
7063.2Jon Moskowitz
7162.9Charles R. Cross
7262.7Gil Kaufman
7362.6Gary Graff
7462.6Daniel Durchholz
7562.5Andrew Dansby
7662.4Ken Capobianco
7762.3Dan DeLuca
7862.2Steve Matteo
7962.2K. Sanneh
8061.9Scott Mervis
8161.8Glenn Gamboa
8261.8Kyle Munson
8361.2John Milward
8461.1Greg Milner
8561.1Jaime Lowe
8660.9Mara Schwartz
8760.8John Vettese
8860.8Bud Scoppa
8960.6Jennifer Vineyard
9060.6Timothy Davis
9160.6Jon Bream
9260.5Charles Johnson
9360.5Rene Saller
9460.4David Menconi
9560.2Greg Kot
9660.2Mark Pytlik
9759.9Clifford J. Corcoran
9859.8Brian Orloff
9959.3Bob Grossweiner
10059.1Thor Christensen
10158.5Jeff Greenblatt
10258.4John Lewis
10358.2Kembrew McLeod
10457.7Karla Peterson
10557.3Steve Dollar
10657.2Sia Michel
10757.1Ted Cox
10856.9Scott Wilson
10956.8Jon Dolan
11056.8Roy Trakin
11156.8Molly Priesmeyer
11256.7Rod Perez
11356.6Erik Pedersen
11456.3Tom Sinclair
11556.0Chris Willman
11655.7John Elsasser
11755.3Sasha Frere-Jones
11855.0Josh Love
11955.0Rob Sheffield
12055.0Ivan Kreilkamp
12155.0Steve Kiviat
12254.7George Yatchisin
12354.5Alex Stimmel
12454.4J. Anthony Ware
12554.4Seth Mnookin
12654.3Patrick Berkery
12754.2Rick Petreycik
12854.1Pat Pierson
12953.9Steve Reynolds
13053.8Tony Fletcher
13153.6Stacy Osbaum
13253.6Danny Hooley
13353.5Brian M. Raftery
13453.3Amaheed Alani
13553.1Jon Pareles
13652.8David Bratton
13752.3Ethan Covey
13852.1Sarah Rodman
13952.1Joe Heim
14052.0Laura DeMarco
14152.0Jodi Shapiro
14252.0Tom Lane
14351.9Smith Galtney
14451.8Arion Berger
14551.7Joshua Leeman
14651.6Mark Watt
14751.5Neil Strauss
14851.4Rob Tannenbaum
14951.3Ron Hart
15051.2Marianne Meyer
15151.1Franklin Soults
15250.8Rachel Leibrock
15350.3Gina Vivinetto
15450.3Shirley Halperin
15550.2Anders Smith Lindall
15650.1P. Gregory Springer
15750.1Marc Greilsamer
15850.1Michael Goldberg
15950.0Mary Huhn
16050.0Tom Terrell
16149.9David Jarman
16249.5Hua Hsu
16349.3Barry Walters
16449.1George Varga
16549.1Dave Lindquist
16649.0David Browne
16748.8Dean Johnson
16848.8Scott Morrow
16948.8Bill Holdship
17048.7Stephanie Zacharek
17148.6Mikael Wood
17248.6Matt Diehl
17348.5Ed Masley
17448.4Sarah Sternau
17548.3Leah Greenblatt
17648.2A.S. Van Dorston
17748.2David John Farinella
17848.1Christian Hoard
17948.1Michelle Kleinsak
18048.0Ben Greenman
18147.9Rod Pocowatchit
18247.9Melissa Ruggieri
18347.8Allison Stewart
18447.8Barney Hoskyns
18547.8Mark Harden
18647.5Mark J. LePage
18747.3Josh Modell
18847.1Carey Price
18946.9Joe Levy
19046.8Stephen Thomas Erlewine
19146.8Emily Goldberg
19246.8Peter Margasak
19346.8Peter Scholtes
19446.7Renee Graham
19546.7Tricia Romano
19646.6Jody Rosen
19746.5Randall Roberts
19846.4Chris Ryan
19946.3Michael Tatum
20046.3David Sprague
20146.2Mark Sinker
20246.0Steve Connell
20346.0Bob Mehr
20445.7J. Edward Keyes
20545.6Sean Howe
20645.4Jeff Perlah
20745.4Oscar Garza
20845.3Trent Fitzgerald
20945.2Daniel Piotrowski
21044.7Roni Sarig
21144.6Chuck Klosterman
21244.6Michael Jarrett
21344.3Evan Serpick
21444.1Ted Friedman
21544.0Holly Gleason
21643.8Chris Riemenschneider
21743.8Joe Gross
21843.5Thomas Golianopoulous
21943.4Bob Townsend
22043.4James Sullivan
22143.3Patricia Deluca
22243.3Alec Hanley Bemis
22343.1Katherine Spielmann
22443.0Curtis Ross
22542.9Kevin O'Hare
22642.7Dove a.k.a Rhoda Clark
22742.6Joshua Goldfein
22842.3Greg Siegel
22942.3Daniel Marek
23042.3Clay Steakley
23142.1Ben Sisario
23242.1Martin Johnson
23341.9Craig Marks
23441.8Brett McCabe
23541.7Brett Sokol
23641.6Lauren Viera
23741.6Shawn Edwards
23841.5Jonathan Perry
23941.4John McPartlin
24041.4Jenny Eliscu
24141.4Ezra Feinberg
24241.4Eric Weisbard
24341.3Anthony DeCurtis
24441.3Christopher Blagg
24541.2J.D. Considine
24641.0Billy Shand
24740.9Ken Tucker
24840.9Matt Ashare
24940.7Doug Pullen
25040.6Robin A. Rothman
25140.4Christina Saraceno
25240.3Matt Hickey
25340.2Norm Elrod
25439.9Miles Marshall Lewis
25539.8Nick Catucci
25639.8Lang Thompson
25739.6Alison Prato
25839.6Richard Martin
25939.4Gaylord Fields
26039.4Sal Caputo
26139.2Matt Hendrickson
26239.2Jerry Dannemiller
26339.2Dan Aloi
26439.1JoE Silva
26538.9Andrew Miller
26638.8Ann Powers
26738.7Bo Pogue
26838.7Kenny Berkowitz
26938.5John Soeder
27038.4Peter Terzian
27138.4Pete Glowatsky
27238.4Rick de Yampert
27338.4Dylan Siegler
27438.3G. Brown
27537.9Jonathon Stuart
27637.9Tim Pratt
27737.8Jason Buhrmester
27837.6Rick Reger
27937.6Timothy Finn
28037.6Meredith Ochs
28137.3Bryan Thomas
28237.2Richard Skanse
28337.0Michael Gonzales
28437.0Ernest Hardy
28537.0Stephen Thompson
28636.9Dan Ouellette
28736.6Rickey Wright
28836.5Greg Beets
28936.5Shannon Zimmerman
29036.4Scott Schinder
29136.3David Prince
29236.3Melissa Maerz
29336.3Shane Harrison
29436.2Noel Murray
29536.2Matthew Fritch
29636.2Rob Harvilla
29736.1J.R. Nelson
29835.9Adrienne Day
29935.8Bo Gilliland
30035.7Eric Broome
30135.6Hillary Rea
30235.6Geoffrey Himes
30335.5Tim Grierson
30435.3Ryan DeGama
30535.3Judith Kaufman
30635.3Larry Katz
30735.2David Segal
30835.1Werner Trieschmann
30935.1Richard C. Walls
31035.1Eric T. Miller
31135.0Steve Hochman
31234.8Ethan Brown
31334.7Vaughn Watson
31434.6David Shirley
31534.5Bart Becker
31634.5Jason Cohen
31734.5Lawrence Kay
31834.3Keith Harris
31933.9Matt Ryan
32033.9Rick Mitchell
32133.9Jem Aswad
32233.8Tim Riley
32333.8Joshunda Victoria Sanders
32433.7Maura Johnston
32533.7Natalie Nichols
32633.7Ken Micallef
32733.7Oliver Wang
32833.5Bobby Tanzilo
32933.5Kevin John
33033.4Connie Johnson
33133.4Vince Aletti
33233.2Jaan Uhelszki
33333.0Scott Henkemeyer
33432.9Craig Smith
33532.8Troy Brookins
33632.7Amy Phillips
33732.5Jonah Bayer
33832.5Dave Gil de Rubio
33932.4Cyndi Elliott
34032.4Russell Carlson
34132.4Chris Herrington
34232.4John Fortunato
34332.2Amy Linden
34432.1Lissa Townsend Rodgers
34532.0Jeanne Fury
34631.9Ken Richardson
34731.9Steve Ciabattoni
34831.8Robert Christgau
34931.7Todd S. Inoue
35031.7Malcolm Mayhew
35131.6Kem Poston
35231.6Corey Moss
35331.5Holly George-Warren
35431.4Jillian Steinberger
35531.3Don Kaye
35631.2Jay Ruttenberg
35731.2Les Scurry
35831.2Wayne Bledsoe
35931.2Debbie Guirand
36030.8Randy Lewis
36130.6Britt Robson
36230.2Lisa Levy
36329.9Milo Miles
36429.8Tim Finney
36529.8Kenyon Hopkin
36629.6Jim Fouratt
36729.5Jenny Tatone
36829.5Tom Cheyney
36929.5Lloyd Sachs
37029.5Michael Azerrad
37129.4Rob Geary
37229.3Hobey Echlin
37329.3Laura Sinagra
37429.3A.D. Amorosi
37529.2Annie Zaleski
37629.1Nelson George
37729.0Tad Hendrickson
37828.9Stuart Berman
37928.8Nicole Elyse
38028.8Michaelangelo Matos
38128.8Jim Meyer
38228.7Jonathan Gold
38328.6Donnell Suggs
38428.4Marc Ferris
38528.4Jason Pettigrew
38628.1James Hannaham
38728.1Bob Ruggiero
38827.9Chris M. Junior
38927.8Jazzbo/Joseph Patel
39027.8Jeremy Helligar
39127.7Tom Hull
39227.7Mike McGonigal
39327.7Margeaux Watson
39427.3Chris Handyside
39527.3Lisa Garrett
39627.1Todd Hutlock
39727.1Bill Ellis
39827.0Daphne Carr
39926.9Dana Buoniconti
40026.9Anthony Mariani
40126.7Piotr Orlov
40226.7M.J. Fine
40326.6Rob Michaels
40426.5Glenn Dixon
40526.5Steve Horowitz
40626.4Michael Curtin
40726.3Scott Woods
40826.3Nathan Rabin
40926.3Jessica Hopper
41026.0Jennifer Schwartz
41125.9Jason Ferguson
41225.9Billy Altman
41325.9Michael Alan Goldberg
41425.8Tom Ewing
41525.7Steve Pick
41625.7Ta-Nehisi Coates
41725.6Mike Rubin
41825.6Rob Marriott
41925.3Ashlea Halpern
42025.2Gene Stout
42125.1Sonia Murray
42225.1Eric Snider
42325.1Ira Robbins
42424.8Tom Laskin
42524.8Howard Cohen
42624.7Charles Aaron
42724.7Ken Scrudato
42824.6Jason Gross
42924.6Linda Ray
43024.6Glenn Kenny
43124.4Kris Chen
43224.4Michael Paoletta
43324.3Andy Greenwald
43424.3Kara Manning
43524.2Stephen W. Terrell
43624.2Thomas May
43724.1Rob Kemp
43823.9Anthony Miccio
43923.8Michael Krugman
44023.6Josh Kun
44123.6Dave Clifford
44223.4Damien Lemon
44323.0Lynne Johnson
44423.0Matt Corwine
44523.0Randall Grass
44622.9Andy Wang
44722.6Dennis Lim
44822.5Alex Henderson
44922.3Albert Mudrian
45022.2Kok Kian Goh
45122.0Leland Rucker
45222.0Rosemary Passantino
45322.0Kurt B. Reighley
45421.8Brent Burton
45521.8Kimberly Chun
45621.7Bill Friskics-Warren
45721.7Larry King
45821.6Chuck Campbell
45921.4Michael Cimicata
46021.4Michael Point
46121.3Brock Phillips
46221.2Josh Kortbein
46321.0Marc Weisblott
46420.9Nathaniel Hawks
46520.7Mark Jenkins
46620.7Richard Torres
46720.5Lola Emanuelli
46820.5Josh Norek
46920.4Neil Drumming
47020.0Dave Tompkins
47120.0Sean Richardson
47220.0Tony Engelhart
47320.0Jim Connelly
47419.9Andy Battaglia
47519.9David Cantwell
47619.9Tom Pryor
47719.7Jess Harvell
47819.7Charlotte Robinson
47919.7Jim Farber
48019.6Don Allred
48119.6Andrew Strickman
48219.5Jon Caramanica
48319.4Rod Smith
48419.2Gary Jackson
48519.1Carola Dibbell
48618.8Jeff Chang
48718.7Hillary Chute
48818.5dream hampton
48918.5Dave DiMartino
49018.4Spence D.
49118.4Steve Morse
49218.3Jim Macnie
49318.2Paul Clements
49418.2Chris Baty
49517.9William Werde
49617.9David Thorpe
49717.9Joseph Robinson
49817.7Kandia Crazy Horse
49917.6Ken Gibbs
50017.3Nana Brew-Hammond
50117.2Andrew Nash
50217.1Kate Silver
50317.0Greil Marcus
50416.9Don McLeese
50516.9Aaron Burgess
50616.8Charlie Braxton
50716.8Scott Holter
50816.8Jim Testa
50916.6Alex Reynolds
51016.6Greg Tate
51116.6Jimmy Draper
51216.5Sam Hunt
51316.5Douglas Wolk
51416.4K. Leander Williams
51516.4Bill Eichenberger
51616.4Steven Ward
51716.3Yancey Strickler
51816.3Todd Kristel
51916.3Derek Beres
52016.3Peter Davis
52116.3Kim Taylor
52216.2Derk Richardson
52316.2Peter Blackstock
52416.1Alex Ross
52516.1Jeremy Tepper
52616.0Sean Carruthers
52716.0Jim Bessman
52815.9Simon Reynolds
52915.8Kiki Yablon
53015.8Peter Shapiro
53115.7Carlo Wolff
53215.5Susan Moll
53315.5Cecile Cloutier
53415.5Franklin Paul
53515.3Greg Casseus
53615.3Fred M. Mills
53715.2Sean Glennon
53815.0Adam Bregman
53915.0Rich Kane
54014.7Grant Alden
54114.7Pete Babb
54214.6Franklin Bruno
54314.6Elisabeth Vincentelli
54414.3Tim Midgett
54514.3Mike Mettler
54614.1Brian O'Neill
54714.0James Hunter
54814.0Jane Dark
54914.0Scott Seward
55013.9Josh Davidson
55113.9Karen Iris Tucker
55213.7Spencer Kaufman
55313.7Chuck Eddy
55413.6Marc Weidenbaum
55513.5Mike Wolf
55613.4Steve Boughton
55713.2Richard Gehr
55813.1Jeff Tamarkin
55912.9Phillip Overeem
56012.9Daniel DiMaggio
56112.8Darrell M. McNeill
56212.7Jill Blardinelli
56312.7Doug Brod
56412.4Steven Blush
56512.4Sara Sherr
56612.3Kevin R. Convey
56712.3Andy Kellman
56812.3Serena Kim
56912.2Fred Cisterna
57012.0Andrew Hamlin
57111.9Jean Lee
57211.9Sean Portnoy
57311.8Tristam Lozaw
57411.7Rico Washington
57511.4Steve Bloom
57611.4Jeffrey Herrmann
57711.3Fred Shuster
57811.2Mark Prindle
57910.9Anastasia Pantsios
58010.6Howard Wuelfing
58110.4Richard Juzwiak
58210.4Daniel King
58310.3Kingsley Marshall
58410.2Michael Lipton
58510.2John Chandler
58610.2Craig Seymour
58710.2Arsenio Orteza
58810.2William Ruhlmann
58910.1John Walker
59010.1Carly Carioli
59110.0Robert Johnson
5929.9Sara Marcus
5939.9Tim Haslett
5949.9Jim Musser
5959.8Pamela Murray Winters
5969.7Marc Gilman
5979.5Barry Mazor
5989.5Michael Freedberg
5999.5Pat Blashill
6009.5Emerson Dameron
6019.4Matt Rogers
6028.7Paul Lukas
6038.4Lee Froehlich
6048.2Enrique Lavin
6058.0Theo Thimou
6068.0Tom Semioli
6077.7Banning Eyre
6087.6Falling James
6097.4Dave Segal
6107.4Chris Smith
6117.2Marty Lipp
6127.2Rob O'Connor
6137.1Dara Cook
6146.9Dan Strachota
6156.7David Lawrence Dunlap Jr.
6166.7Mosi Reeves
6176.4Otis Hart
6186.4Joshua Gabriel
6196.3Tim Mohr
6206.3Tim Ellison
6216.1Jessie Nelson
6226.0Michael Daddino
6235.9Gail Worley
6245.8Philip Sherburne
6255.7Sterling Clover
6265.5Jon Whitney
6275.5Carol Cooper
6285.1Chairman Jefferson Mao
6295.1Bill Meyer
6305.0Bill Milkowski
6314.9Ken Shimamoto
6324.6Ramiro Burr
6334.6Diego Hadis
6344.5Adam McGovern
6354.4J. Eric Smith
6364.3Mike McGuirk
6374.3Hank Bordowitz
6384.3Darren Ressler
6394.2Dale Lawrence
6404.2Andrew Scott Earles
6414.2John Wojtowicz
6424.1Will York
6434.0Larry Birnbaum
6443.9Shawn Bosler
6453.8Heidi Siegmund Cuda
6463.8glenn mcdonald
6473.8Chuy Varela
6483.7Julio Diaz
6493.5Phil Freeman
6503.5Bill Holmes
6513.4Will Romano
6523.2Greg Burk
6533.1Tony Tranfa
6543.1Frank Kogan
6553.1Ben Ratliff
6563.0Paul Semel
6572.9Charlie Wilmoth
6582.9Ken Roseman
6592.8Leonard Roberge
6602.8Troy J. Augusto
6612.7Liz Armstrong
6622.7Jacob Edgar
6632.6J. R. Taylor
6642.4Brian Smith
6652.4Jack Rabid
6662.2Byron Coley
6672.1Eric Bensel
6682.1Bryan Reesman
6691.8Nathan Birk
6701.8Tom Smucker
6711.7Heath Hignight
6721.6George Petros
6731.5John Mincemoyer
6741.5Mike Saunders
6751.4Richard Riegel
6761.2Robert Nedelkoff
6771.1Glenn Donaldson
6780.9Paul-Emile Comeau
6790.7Sly Stallone
6800.7Kim Cooper
6810.7Jud Cost
6820.6Vinnie Apicella
6830.6David M. Snyder
6840.5Deena Dasein
6850.4Judson Kilpatrick
6860.4Jordan Mamone
6870.4Gil Gershman
6880.3Tom Surowicz
6890.3George Smith
6900.3Deborah Price
6910.3Laura Cassidy
6920.0Stacy Meyn
Site contents published by glenn mcdonald under a Creative Commons BY/NC/ND License except where otherwise noted.