furia furialog · New Particles · The War Against Silence · Aedliga (songs) · photography · code · other things     ↑vF
2003 Pazz & Jop critical alignment ratings
Here are the voters in the 2003 Village Voice Pazz & Jop Critics' Poll, ranked according to the average number of other voters who voted for each of their album picks. If anyone had voted for the exact ten 2003 album winners, their rating would have been 121.3; anyone casting only five votes for the top five albums would have been rated 168. My own opinions were marginally more popular than usual this year.
This analysis is also available for 2002, 2001 and 2000.
rank rating voter
1139.0Miles Marshall Lewis
2105.1Mark Zepezauer
3103.9Sia Michel
4102.8L. Kent Wolgamott
5101.5Ivan Kreilkamp
6101.3Keith Phipps
799.6Marc Spitz
898.4Eric Weisbard
997.5Josh Tyrangiel
1097.3Rickey Wright
1196.5Alec Foege
1296.2Anthony Mariani
1395.8Joshua Goldfein
1495.2Glenn Gamboa
1594.9Tracey Pepper
1694.6Gina Vivinetto
1794.4Neva Chonin
1893.8Gary Chun
1993.7P. Gregory Springer
2093.6Tom Lane
2193.1Zac Crain
2292.8Barry Walters
2392.7Ken Rayes
2492.1Jonathan Valania
2591.7Craig Marks
2690.3George Yatchisin
2789.7Joe Hagan
2889.7Thee-O
2989.7Dave Lipp
3089.6Will Hermes
3189.4Steve Reynolds
3289.4Chris Norris
3388.8Mark J. LePage
3488.3Jim Tremayne
3587.9Stephen Mooallem
3687.8Karla Peterson
3787.8Nana Brew-Hammond
3887.2Sal Caputo
3987.0Heather Phares
4087.0Jennifer Vineyard
4186.9Angela Cravens
4286.8Ed Condran
4386.4J. Anthony Ware
4485.6Stephen W. Terrell
4585.5Ben Wener
4685.4Gary Jackson
4785.2Christopher O'Connor
4885.1James Hannaham
4984.5Richard Cromelin
5084.0Judith Kaufman
5183.1Jim Walsh
5283.0Jon Wiederhorn
5382.9Greg Milner
5482.6Ricardo Baca
5582.5Kevin O'Donnell
5682.3Michael Gallucci
5782.1Bud Scoppa
5882.0David Menconi
5981.9Jim Connelly
6081.9Roy Trakin
6181.8Ben Greenman
6281.7Gary Graff
6381.4Mark Athitakis
6481.4Eyder Peralta
6581.3Bo Pogue
6681.3Julie Taraska
6781.3Patrick Berkery
6880.8Joe D'Angelo
6980.4Steven Mirkin
7080.3Toure Toure
7180.1Anthony Miccio
7279.9Al Choman
7379.6Robert Hilburn
7479.6Paul Robicheau
7579.4Max Berry
7679.3Chris Nelson
7779.0Jem Aswad
7878.9Patricia Grandjean
7978.6Stephanie Zacharek
8078.5Tom Moon
8178.0Richard Martin
8278.0David Wild
8377.6Corey du Browa
8477.6Sacha Jenkins
8577.4Chris Willman
8677.4Jamiyla Chisholm
8777.1Jon Pareles
8877.0Erik Pedersen
8977.0Scott Floman
9076.9Ed Masley
9176.6Spencer Kaufman
9276.6David Segal
9376.4Brian Orloff
9476.2Ted Cox
9575.7Stephen Thomas Erlewine
9675.7Steve May
9775.7Caryn B. Brooks
9875.3Alan Light
9975.2C.B. Baldwin
10074.9Clifford J. Corcoran
10174.4Allison Stewart
10274.4John Soeder
10373.6Robert Johnson
10473.3Jeff Jackson
10573.3Steve Hochman
10673.1Randall Roberts
10773.0Jon Jon Scott
10872.9Jody Rosen
10972.9Laura DeMarco
11072.8Daniel Durchholz
11172.2Andi Zeisler
11272.2Dan DeLuca
11371.9John Lewis
11471.8Chris Macias
11571.8Jon Moskowitz
11671.7Cyndi Elliott
11771.1Steve Knopper
11871.0Ken Tucker
11970.8Daniel Marek
12070.2Rashaun Hall
12170.1Tom Sinclair
12269.8Ezra Feinberg
12369.6Smith Galtney
12469.4Sasha Frere-Jones
12569.2Jesus Trevino
12668.9Nick Marino
12768.3Rob Tannenbaum
12867.6Rick Reger
12967.4Shane Harrison
13067.3Joshua Leeman
13167.3Jeff Perlah
13266.5Philip Martin
13366.3Irin Carmon
13466.3Joe Heim
13566.1Kiki Yablon
13665.9Nancy Einhart
13765.8Dave Lindquist
13865.6Matt Sebastian
13965.5Tony Norman
14065.5Troy Brookins
14165.1Anthony Bozza
14265.1Michael Endelman
14365.0Randy Lewis
14464.9Lynne Johnson
14564.7Alison Prato
14664.7Larry Katz
14764.6Steven Chean
14864.4Jason Fine
14964.3Steve Klinge
15064.2Ken Capobianco
15164.2Richard Abowitz
15264.2Michael Jarrett
15364.1Malcolm Mayhew
15463.7Alec Hanley Bemis
15563.7Ta-Nehisi Coates
15663.7A.D. Amorosi
15763.6Phil Gallo
15863.4Albert Mudrian
15963.3Rachel Devitt
16063.1Jim Sullivan
16162.9Ted Friedman
16262.9Craig Smith
16362.7Tom Laskin
16462.6RJ Smith
16562.4Tom Semioli
16662.0Chuck Klosterman
16761.5James Sullivan
16861.3Carlo Wolff
16961.3Greg Kot
17061.2Shirley Halperin
17161.2Charles Aaron
17261.2Josh Kun
17361.0Marc Ferris
17460.9Danny Hooley
17560.9Rob Sheffield
17660.8Ben Sisario
17760.5Alex Pappademas
17860.2David Fricke
17960.1Dennis Cooper
18060.0Janna Chan
18159.9Greg Beets
18259.8Andy Gensler
18359.7Nikhil Swaminathan
18459.5Nelson George
18559.5Lisa Garrett
18659.4Nate Patrin
18759.4Jessica Winter
18859.2Tim Pratt
18959.1Adam Miller
19059.0Stacy Osbaum
19159.0Ken Richardson
19258.8David Sprague
19358.7Jonathan Stuart
19458.7Ann Powers
19558.5Mac Randall
19657.8Don Waller
19757.7Margeaux Watson
19857.7Caryn Ganz
19957.1Noel Murray
20056.9Erik Himmelsbach
20156.8Steve Horowitz
20256.6Julianne Shepherd
20356.6Jim Macnie
20456.6Brian M. Raftery
20556.5Kirk Miller
20656.3Josh Davidson
20756.3Jaime Lowe
20856.2Andrew Miller
20956.0Gaylord Fields
21055.7Cate Smith
21155.4Vince Aletti
21255.3Thomas Golianopoulos
21355.3Sarah Rodman
21455.0Ryan Smith
21555.0David Browne
21655.0Timothy Finn
21754.9Thomas May
21854.9Hobey Echlin
21954.6Amy Phillips
22054.3John Bush
22154.3Adrienne Day
22254.1Melissa Maerz
22354.1Sonia Murray
22454.0Steve Kiviat
22554.0Scott Mervis
22653.9Chris Riemenschneider
22753.9Dan Reines
22853.8Neil Strauss
22953.6Thomas Inskeep
23053.5Larry King
23153.4Jim Fouratt
23253.4J. Edward Keyes
23353.3Rob Kemp
23453.2Michael Paoletta
23553.2David Simutis
23653.2Andrew Strickman
23753.0Rob Geary
23853.0Kurt B. Reighley
23952.9Bob Townsend
24052.7Peter Margasak
24152.5Roni Sarig
24252.5Gil Kaufman
24352.5Joshua Clover
24452.4Stephen M. Deusner
24552.0Hua Hsu
24651.9Amy Linden
24751.9Allen St. John
24851.8Raquel Cepeda
24951.8Marc Greilsamer
25051.7Alex Ross
25151.4Devon Powers
25251.2Jimmy Draper
25351.1Josh Modell
25451.1James Tai
25551.1Nathan Rabin
25650.9Andrew Bartlett
25750.8Trevor Kelley
25850.8Tristram Lozaw
25950.7Kevin O'Hare
26050.7Chris Herrington
26150.6Ken Gibbs
26250.4Rick Massimo
26350.0Jonah Weiner
26449.7Lang Thompson
26549.7Damien Lemon
26649.6Joshua Fahiym Ratcliffe
26749.5Franklin Bruno
26849.2Jon Bream
26949.2Carey Price
27049.2Rob Kenner
27149.1Jon Matsumoto
27249.1Michael Deeds
27348.7Tim Midgett
27448.7Don McLeese
27548.3Britt Robson
27648.3Kimberly Chun
27747.9Ken Switzer
27847.9Oscar Garza
27947.7Amy Schroeder
28047.7Todd Hutlock
28147.3Jenny Eliscu
28247.2Lola Emanuelli
28347.1Joe Gross
28446.9Dan Strachota
28546.8Holly George-Warren
28646.6John Vettese
28746.6Enrique Lavin
28846.5Franklin Paul
28946.5Chairman Jefferson Mao
29046.4Jim DeRogatis
29146.4Philip Sherburne
29246.1Hillary Chute
29346.1Grant Moser
29446.0Michael Barthel
29546.0Rob Brunner
29645.9Joshunda Victoria Sanders
29745.3Michael Azerrad
29845.3Nicole Elyse
29945.1Ron Hart
30045.0Soren Baker
30145.0Richard Torres
30244.9Kris Ex
30344.8Michelle Kleinsak
30444.6Kyle Munson
30544.5Brent Burton
30644.5Pete Glowatsky
30744.4Lloyd Sachs
30844.3Shawn Edwards
30944.2Jonathan Perry
31044.1Jeff Chang
31143.1Chris Handyside
31243.0Steve Morse
31342.8Joshua Klein
31442.7Kenji Jasper
31542.6Rob Michaels
31642.3Mara Schwartz
31742.1Kay Bourne
31842.1Mike Rubin
31942.0Daniel Aquilante
32041.9Leah Greenblatt
32141.7Joseph McCombs
32241.7Charles R. Cross
32341.6David Cantwell
32441.3Brian Howard
32541.3Mikael Wood
32641.2Jessica Hopper
32741.1Charlie Braxton
32841.1Dan Aloi
32941.1Kara Manning
33041.0Robin A. Rothman
33141.0J. Eric Smith
33240.6Glenn Kenny
33340.6Adam Bregman
33440.6Matt Ashare
33540.3Laura Sinagra
33640.0Elena Oumano
33740.0Renee Graham
33839.9Natalie Nichols
33939.9Fred M. Mills
34039.8Sean Richardson
34139.8Jason Ferguson
34239.7Jenny Tatone
34339.5Bob Ruggiero
34439.5Fred Cisterna
34539.5Kimberly Merritt
34639.5Howard Cohen
34739.2Steve Bloom
34839.1Trent Fitzgerald
34938.7Laurence Station
35038.5Dave Stelfox
35138.5Todd S. Inoue
35238.4Paul Cox
35338.4Charles Johnson
35438.4Neil Drumming
35538.2Piotr Orlov
35638.0Sherman Johnson
35738.0Rich Kane
35837.9Michael McCall
35937.8Bill Holdship
36037.8John Fortunato
36137.7Dan Epstein
36237.6Seth Mnookin
36337.6Marianne Meyer
36437.4Joseph Patel
36537.4Jason Cohen
36637.3Jon Dolan
36737.2Greg Tate
36837.2Tad Hendrickson
36937.1Chris Lorraine
37037.0Joe Levy
37136.9Yancey Strickler
37236.9Patrick Rapa
37336.9Kenyon Hopkin
37436.7M.J. Fine
37536.7Mike Mettler
37636.5Josh Love
37736.4Jim Farber
37836.3Ken Micaleff
37936.1JoE Silva
38036.1Robert Christgau
38135.8Lissa Townsend Rodgers
38235.8Brian O'Neill
38335.8Celeste Dawn Mitchell
38435.8Scott Plagenhoef
38535.6Beth Wawerna
38635.4Viva Las Vegas
38735.4Phillip Overeem
38835.4Michaelangelo Matos
38935.2Rick Petreycik
39035.0Dylan Hicks
39134.9Shawn Bosler
39234.8Troy J. Augusto
39334.7Ben Ratliff
39434.2Cecile Cloutier
39534.0Rod Smith
39634.0Mary Huhn
39733.3Peter Terzian
39833.1Marc Gilman
39933.0Michael Krugman
40033.0Debra Desalvo
40132.9Charlie Wilmoth
40232.8Stuart Berman
40332.8Dave Tompkins
40432.5Katherine Spielmann
40532.5Eric Demby
40632.4Barry Mazor
40732.2Brett Sokol
40832.0Ira Robbins
40932.0Sean Carruthers
41032.0Stephen Thompson
41131.8Emily Goldberg
41231.8Tim Grierson
41331.7Dean Johnson
41431.5Ashlea Halpern
41531.5A.S. Van Dorston
41631.4Kimberlye Gold
41731.4Falling James
41831.3Jeanne Fury
41931.3Lauren Viera
42031.2Matt Rogers
42131.1Aidin Vaziri
42231.0Eric T. Miller
42330.8Keith Harris
42430.5Jason Gross
42530.3Roy Kasten
42630.2J.D. Considine
42730.2Steve Ciabattoni
42830.2Michael Tatum
42930.0Corey Moss
43030.0Rosemary Passantino
43129.9Kelefa Sanneh
43229.8Scott Woods
43329.8Steve Matteo
43429.7David J. Prince
43529.4Christian Hoard
43629.4Franklin Soults
43729.4Scott Holter
43829.4Christopher Weingarten
43929.3Dana Buoniconti
44029.3Werner Trieschmann
44129.2Serena Kim
44229.1Jim Testa
44329.0Oliver Wang
44428.5Thor Christensen
44528.3Billy Altman
44628.3William Werde
44728.1Bob Grossweiner
44827.9John McPartlin
44927.9Tim Mohr
45027.8Matthew Fritch
45127.7Sean Glennon
45227.6David Shirley
45327.3Andy Greenwald
45427.3Carla DeSantis
45527.2Glenn Dixon
45627.1Rod Perez
45727.1andy beta
45827.0Jess Harvell
45926.9Milo Miles
46026.6Daniel DiMaggio
46126.5Andy Battaglia
46226.5Kok Kian Goh
46326.4Michael Nelson
46426.4Jon Caramanica
46526.2Steve Simels
46625.9Andrew Hamlin
46725.9Michael Cimicata
46825.8Rob Harvilla
46925.8Joe Harrington
47025.8Steve Erickson
47125.6Jason Pettigrew
47225.4Michael Goldberg
47325.4Richard Skanse
47425.4Geeta Dayal
47525.4Parke Puterbaugh
47625.3Mike Pelusi
47725.3Kevin John
47825.2John Elsasser
47925.1Mike McGonigal
48025.0Dennis Lim
48124.7Ned Raggett
48224.6Andrew Dansby
48324.6Kevin Moreau
48424.5Jolie Lash
48524.3Hank Bordowitz
48624.1Meredith Ochs
48723.9Erich Scholz
48823.9Dan Ouellette
48923.8John Everhart
49023.6Pat Pierson
49123.5Carrie Havranek
49223.4Tony Fletcher
49323.1Wayne Bledsoe
49422.8Erik Parker
49522.8Bill Holmes
49622.8Marcello Carlin
49722.8Nick Catucci
49822.7Tim Sendra
49922.5Carly Carioli
50022.3Tim Finney
50122.2Jack Rabid
50222.2James Hunter
50322.2Jeff Johnson
50422.2Mark Pytlik
50522.1Andy Wang
50621.9George Varga
50721.8Andrew Scott Earles
50821.8Brett Lanier
50921.7Anders Smith Lindall
51021.5Scott Wilson
51121.2Rachel Leibrock
51221.2John Milward
51320.7Jessie Nelson
51420.6Jill Blardinelli
51520.5Doug Brod
51620.3Brian Block
51720.3Tom Ewing
51819.8Mark Prindle
51919.5Billy Shand
52019.3Daphne Carr
52119.2Andy Kellman
52219.2Chris Baty
52319.1George A. Paul
52419.1Greil Marcus
52518.9Karen Iris Tucker
52618.8Jay Ruttenberg
52718.7Tony Engelhart
52818.6Matt Hickey
52918.6Kate Silver
53018.5Brian Smith
53118.5Amanda Petrusich
53218.3Tim Riley
53318.3David Prince
53418.2Chuck Campbell
53518.0Norm Elrod
53617.9Steve Connell
53717.9Dave DiMartino
53817.7Bill Friskics-Warren
53917.6Dara Cook
54016.6Geoffrey Himes
54116.5Mark Jenkins
54216.3Craig Seymour
54316.2Baz Dreisinger
54416.0Jody Beth Rosen
54516.0Kandia Crazy Horse
54616.0Steve Rosen
54715.6Carry Over Ballots
54815.6Elisabeth Vincentelli
54915.5Sterling Clover
55015.4Andrew Nash
55115.4Jerry Dannemiller
55215.1Sara Sherr
55315.1Jim Meyer
55415.0Steven Ward
55515.0Tim Haslett
55614.5Michael Curtin
55714.5Douglas Wolk
55814.0Jon Young
55914.0Jonathan Garrett
56013.9Ethan Padgett
56113.7Chris Ryan
56213.6Steve Pick
56313.6Sean Portnoy
56413.5Dev Sherlock
56513.3John Chandler
56613.1Jeremy Tepper
56713.1Annie Zaleski
56812.9Mosi Reeves
56912.8Tech Guerrero
57012.6Sean Howe
57112.2Chris M. Junior
57212.1Kris Chen
57311.9Johnny Ray Huston
57411.8Leland Rucker
57511.6Josh Norek
57611.5K. Leander Williams
57711.5Pete Babb
57811.5David Bratton
57911.5Will Romano
58011.2John Walker
58111.0Mike Wolf
58210.8Steve Forstneger
58310.8Spence D.
58410.6Peter Shapiro
58510.6Martin Johnson
58610.4Ramiro Burr
5879.9Brett McCabe
5889.8stephen slaybaugh
5899.5Howard Wuelfing
5909.5Pamela Winters
5919.5Laura Cassidy
5929.4Brock Phillips
5939.2Matt Ryan
5949.2Todd Burns
5958.9Tom Hull
5968.9Michael Daddino
5978.8Michael Alan Goldberg
5988.8Maura Johnston
5998.8Frank Kogan
6008.7Jeff Tamarkin
6018.7Jodi Shapiro
6028.7Pamela Murray Winters
6038.6Janet Tzou
6048.5Chuck Eddy
6058.4Simon Reynolds
6068.4Kevin R. Convey
6078.3Matt Cibula
6088.3David Greenberger
6098.2Todd Kristel
6108.2Mykella Van Cooten
6118.1David Bowman
6128.1Rick Mitchell
6138.1Brandon Stosuy
6147.9Paul Semel
6157.9Jascha Hoffman
6167.9Carlton Wade
6177.8Sam Hunt
6187.8Jud Cost
6197.7Jonah Bayer
6207.5Peter Agoston
6217.4Darrell M. McNeill
6227.3Carola Dibbell
6237.3J Poet
6247.3Lalena Fissure
6257.2Bill Meyer
6267.2Peter Blackstock
6276.9Linda Ray
6286.8PJ Gach
6296.8Ethan Covey
6306.8Peter Scholtes
6316.8Dave Clifford
6326.8Dave Segal
6336.7Holly Gleason
6346.6Steve Smith
6356.4Marc Weidenbaum
6366.3Diego Hadis
6376.3Richard Juzwiak
6386.3Matthew Wilder
6395.7Otis Hart
6405.6Jim Musser
6415.5Julio Diaz
6425.5Don Allred
6435.5Heidi Siegmund Cuda
6445.5glenn mcdonald
6455.4Steven Blush
6465.4Daniel King
6475.4Bobby Tanzilo
6485.3Ken Taylor
6495.3Alex Reynolds
6505.2Randall Grass
6515.1Gene Seymour
6525.1Phil Freeman
6535.0Mark Fleischmann
6544.7Robert Nedelkoff
6554.5Michael Lipton
6564.5Leonard Roberge
6574.4Tom Pryor
6584.3Greg Burk
6594.3J. R. Taylor
6604.0Tom Smucker
6614.0Aaron Burgess
6624.0Bart Becker
6634.0Emerson Dameron
6643.9Jon Whitney
6653.8Rob O'Connor
6663.7Joseph Robinson
6673.6Lee Froehlich
6683.5Vinnie Apicella
6693.4Sandy Masuo
6703.4Ken Shimamoto
6713.3Jim Bessman
6723.3Richard Gehr
6733.3George Smith
6743.2Marty Lipp
6752.8Dominique Leone
6762.6Damon Krukowski
6772.5Tony Tranfa
6782.5William Ruhlmann
6792.4Patricia Meschino
6802.4Richard Riegel
6812.4Charlotte Robinson
6822.4Paul Lukas
6832.4Heath Hignight
6842.3Susan Moll
6852.3Scott Seward
6862.2J Neo Marvin
6872.1Derk Richardson
6882.1Adam McGovern
6892.1Gail Worley
6902.0Eugene Holley, Jr.
6912.0Chris Nickson
6922.0Jeffrey Herrmann
6932.0David M. Snyder
6942.0Michael Freedberg
6951.9Derek Beres
6961.9Herb Boyd
6971.7Ken Roseman
6981.6Robin James
6991.5Will York
7001.5Banning Eyre
7011.3Kim Cooper
7021.3Chip Stern
7031.3Paul-Emile Comeau
7041.3Jason Gooder
7051.3Genevieve Powers
7061.2Tim Ellison
7071.2Agustin Gurza
7081.1Justin Farrar
7091.0Jacob Edgar
7100.8David Adler
7110.7Don Share
7120.7Bryan Reesman
7130.6Nathan Birk
7140.6Glenn Donaldson
7150.6Alex Henderson
7160.5Carol Cooper
7170.4Dawn Eden
7180.3Jeffrey Morgan
7190.3Jordan Mamone
7200.3Bill Milkowski
7210.3Deena Dasein
7220.2George Petros
7230.2Stacy Meyn
7240.1John Wojtowicz
7250.0Jose Morillo
7260.0Judson Kilpatrick
Site contents published by glenn mcdonald under a Creative Commons BY/NC/ND License except where otherwise noted.