TWAS 508h: 2006 Jackin' Pop / Pazz & Jop merged results

2006 Jackin' Pop / Pazz & Jop merged results

508h · 8 February 07

Here is the merged album vote-count from the 2006 Idolator Jackin' Pop and 2006 Village Voice Pazz & Jop critics polls, reconciled (hopefully) by voter, artist and album, cut off at a minimum of 10 votes. By my tabulation there were a total of 799 voters who filed ballots in one or both of the polls. Jackin' Pop had 307 voters who didn't vote in Pazz & Jop, Pazz & Jop also had 307 voters who didn't vote in Jackin' Pop, and 185 people voted in both polls. Of the 185 double-voters, 100 filed the same ballots in both polls (ignoring points and ordering, at least), 44 made 1 change, 17 made 2, 6 made 3, 9 made 4, 2 made 5, 2 made 6, 1 made 9, and 2 people filed completely different ballots in the two polls (both of whose P&J ballots look suspiciously like jokes).

For a quick idea of the demographic skew between the two polls, click the Bias heading, which will sort P&J-ish artists to the top, JP-ish artists to the bottom. (No aesthetic judgment of polls or artists is implied by the arbitrary +/- of this math.)

#	Album	Total	JP	P&J	Bias	JP only	P&J only	Both	One
1	TV on the Radio · Return to Cookie Mountain	183	131	99	-0.139	84	52	47	136
2	Ghostface Killah · Fishscale	172	122	99	-0.104	73	50	49	123
3	Clipse · Hell Hath No Fury	133	101	65	-0.217	68	32	33	100
4	Hold Steady · Boys and Girls in America	143	96	82	-0.079	61	47	35	108
5	Joanna Newsom · Ys	118	90	59	-0.208	59	28	31	87
6	Bob Dylan · Modern Times	142	74	97	0.135	45	68	29	113
7	Gnarls Barkley · St. Elsewhere	106	63	71	0.060	35	43	28	78
8	Sonic Youth · Rather Ripped	82	62	51	-0.097	31	20	31	51
9	Neko Case · Fox Confessor Brings the Flood	98	61	64	0.024	34	37	27	71
10	Belle and Sebastian · The Life Pursuit	73	57	38	-0.200	35	16	22	51
10	Hot Chip · The Warning	68	57	30	-0.310	38	11	19	49
12	Arctic Monkeys · Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not	102	55	65	0.083	37	47	18	84
13	Knife · Silent Shout	64	52	32	-0.238	32	12	20	44
14	Cat Power · The Greatest	90	48	56	0.077	34	42	14	76
15	Decemberists · The Crane Wife	74	46	43	-0.034	31	28	15	59
16	Justin Timberlake · FutureSex/Lovesounds	59	45	28	-0.233	31	14	14	45
17	Jenny Lewis with the Watson Twins · Rabbit Fur Coat	61	40	40	0.000	21	21	19	42
18	Girl Talk · Night Ripper	49	38	25	-0.206	24	11	14	35
19	Tom Waits · Orphans: Brawlers, Bawlers and Bastards	72	37	52	0.169	20	35	17	55
19	Destroyer · Destroyer's Rubies	44	37	22	-0.254	22	7	15	29
21	J Dilla · Donuts	48	36	25	-0.180	23	12	13	35
21	T.I. · King	46	36	26	-0.161	20	10	16	30
23	Yo La Tengo · I Am Not Afraid of You and I Will Beat Your Ass	54	35	37	0.028	17	19	18	36
24	Roots · Game Theory	55	33	33	0.000	22	22	11	44
24	Band of Horses · Everything All the Time	53	33	29	-0.065	24	20	9	44
24	Scott Walker · The Drift	41	33	19	-0.269	22	8	11	30
27	Lupe Fiasco · Food and Liquor	48	32	27	-0.085	21	16	11	37
27	Lily Allen · Alright, Still	42	32	25	-0.123	17	10	15	27
29	Yeah Yeah Yeahs · Show Your Bones	49	31	25	-0.107	24	18	7	42
30	My Chemical Romance · The Black Parade	50	30	33	0.048	17	20	13	37
30	Mastodon · Blood Mountain	39	30	16	-0.304	23	9	7	32
32	Regina Spektor · Begin to Hope	42	29	24	-0.094	18	13	11	31
32	Thermals · The Body, the Blood, the Machine	41	29	21	-0.160	20	12	9	32
32	Coup · Pick a Bigger Weapon	40	29	25	-0.074	15	11	14	26
32	Grizzly Bear · Yellow House	37	29	19	-0.208	18	8	11	26
36	Dixie Chicks · Taking the Long Way	42	27	29	0.036	13	15	14	28
37	Bruce Springsteen · We Shall Overcome: the Seeger Sessions	40	23	31	0.148	9	17	14	26
37	Junior Boys · So This is Goodbye	31	23	15	-0.211	16	8	7	24
37	Scritti Politti · White Bread, Black Beer	31	23	19	-0.095	12	8	11	20
37	DJ Drama and Lil Wayne · Dedication 2	28	23	11	-0.353	17	5	6	22
37	Love Is All · Nine Times That Same Song	25	23	11	-0.353	14	2	9	16
42	Thom Yorke · The Eraser	40	22	25	0.064	15	18	7	33
42	Beirut · Gulag Orkestar	28	22	12	-0.294	16	6	6	22
44	Ornette Coleman · Sound Grammar	41	21	27	0.125	14	20	7	34
44	Midlake · The Trials of Van Occupanther	31	21	18	-0.077	13	10	8	23
46	Liars · Drum's Not Dead	26	20	13	-0.212	13	6	7	19
47	Ali Farka Toure · Savane	30	19	18	-0.027	12	11	7	23
48	Raconteurs · Broken Boy Soldiers	41	18	30	0.250	11	23	7	34
48	CSS · Cansei de Ser Sexy	23	18	15	-0.091	8	5	10	13
50	Beck · The Information	33	17	23	0.150	10	16	7	26
50	M. Ward · Post-War	29	17	17	0.000	12	12	5	24
50	Mission of Burma · The Obliterati	28	17	18	0.029	10	11	7	21
50	Peter Bjorn and John · Writer's Block	21	17	10	-0.259	11	4	6	15
54	Neil Young · Living With War	25	16	17	0.030	8	9	8	17
54	Spank Rock · YoYoYoYoYo	25	16	16	0.000	9	9	7	18
54	Brightblack Morning Light · Brightblack Morning Light	19	16	9	-0.280	10	3	6	13
54	Califone · Roots and Crowns	19	16	8	-0.333	11	3	5	14
54	Burial · Burial	18	16	10	-0.231	8	2	8	10
59	Johnny Cash · American V: a Hundred Highways	28	15	22	0.189	6	13	9	19
59	Todd Snider · The Devil You Know	22	15	16	0.032	6	7	9	13
59	Game · Doctor's Advocate	19	15	6	-0.429	13	4	2	17
59	Matmos · The Rose Has Teeth in the Mouth of a Beast	19	15	10	-0.200	9	4	6	13
59	Tim Hecker · Harmony in Ultraviolet	19	15	10	-0.200	9	4	6	13
64	Boris · Pink	20	14	14	0.000	6	6	8	12
64	Blow · Paper Television	16	14	4	-0.556	12	2	2	14
64	Islands · Return to the Sea	15	14	5	-0.474	10	1	4	11
67	Phoenix · It's Never Been Like That	22	13	14	0.037	8	9	5	17
67	Strokes · First Impressions of Earth	22	13	15	0.071	7	9	6	16
67	Camera Obscura · Let's Get Out of This Country	19	13	8	-0.238	11	6	2	17
70	Art Brut · Bang Bang Rock and Roll	19	12	17	0.172	2	7	10	9
70	Scissor Sisters · Ta-Dah	19	12	14	0.077	5	7	7	12
70	Tom Ze · Estudando o Pagode	19	12	15	0.111	4	7	8	11
70	Nas · Hip-Hop Is Dead	18	12	9	-0.143	9	6	3	15
70	Silversun Pickups · Carnavas	16	12	7	-0.263	9	4	3	13
70	Ellen Allien and Apparat · Orchestra of Bubbles	15	12	6	-0.333	9	3	3	12
76	Rosanne Cash · Black Cadillac	30	11	27	0.421	3	19	8	22
76	Rapture · Pieces of the People We Love	17	11	9	-0.100	8	6	3	14
76	Comets On Fire · Avatar	16	11	8	-0.158	8	5	3	13
76	Black Angels · Passover	15	11	7	-0.222	8	4	3	12
76	Final Fantasy · He Poos Clouds	15	11	6	-0.294	9	4	2	13
76	Long Blondes · Someone to Drive You Home	14	11	6	-0.294	8	3	3	11
76	Sunset Rubdown · Shut Up I Am Dreaming	14	11	6	-0.294	8	3	3	11
76	Fiery Furnaces · Bitter Tea	13	11	6	-0.294	7	2	4	9
76	Danielson · Ships	12	11	2	-0.692	10	1	1	11
76	Herbert · Scale	12	11	6	-0.294	6	1	5	7
86	Muse · Black Holes and Revelations	23	10	16	0.231	7	13	3	20
86	Wolfmother · Wolfmother	22	10	17	0.259	5	12	5	17
86	Drive-By Truckers · A Blessing and a Curse	18	10	15	0.200	3	8	7	11
86	LCD Soundsystem · 45:33	18	10	16	0.231	2	8	8	10
86	Pernice Brothers · Live a Little	18	10	13	0.130	5	8	5	13
86	Pearl Jam · Pearl Jam	17	10	12	0.091	5	7	5	12
86	Solomon Burke · Nashville	17	10	11	0.048	6	7	4	13
86	Beyonce · B'Day	16	10	12	0.091	4	6	6	10
86	Mountain Goats · Get Lonely	14	10	9	-0.053	5	4	5	9
86	Toumani Diabate's Symmetric Orchestra · Boulevard de l'Independance	12	10	6	-0.250	6	2	4	8
86	Booka Shade · Movements	11	10	6	-0.250	5	1	5	6
97	New York Dolls · One Day It Will Please Us to Remember Even This	25	9	23	0.438	2	16	7	18
97	Christina Aguilera · Back to Basics	16	9	14	0.217	2	7	7	9
97	Bonnie "Prince" Billy · The Letting Go	15	9	9	0.000	6	6	3	12
97	Juana Molina · Son	15	9	8	-0.059	7	6	2	13
97	Lindsey Buckingham · Under the Skin	15	9	9	0.000	6	6	3	12
97	Be Your Own Pet · Be Your Own Pet	14	9	8	-0.059	6	5	3	11
97	Espers · Espers II	14	9	8	-0.059	6	5	3	11
97	Jarvis Cocker · Jarvis	14	9	10	0.053	4	5	5	9
97	Man Man · Six Demon Bag	13	9	8	-0.059	5	4	4	9
97	Prince · 3121	13	9	8	-0.059	5	4	4	9
97	Ark · State of the Ark	11	9	9	0.000	2	2	7	4
97	Rhymefest · Blue Collar	11	9	3	-0.500	8	2	1	10
109	Elvis Costello and Allen Toussaint · The River in Reverse	27	8	23	0.484	4	19	4	23
109	Beatles · L.O.V.E.	17	8	14	0.273	3	9	5	12
109	Pipettes · We Are the Pipettes	15	8	10	0.111	5	7	3	12
109	Red Hot Chili Peppers · Stadium Arcadium	15	8	9	0.059	6	7	2	13
109	Melvins · (A) Senile Animal	12	8	8	0.000	4	4	4	8
109	J Dilla · The Shining	11	8	7	-0.067	4	3	4	7
109	OOIOO · Taiga	11	8	6	-0.143	5	3	3	8
109	Asobi Seksu · Citrus	10	8	4	-0.333	6	2	2	8
117	Nellie McKay · Pretty Little Head	16	7	13	0.300	3	9	4	12
117	Vince Gill · These Days	15	7	13	0.300	2	8	5	10
117	Built to Spill · You in Reverse	14	7	8	0.067	6	7	1	13
117	Lady Sovereign · Public Warning	14	7	11	0.222	3	7	4	10
117	Twilight Singers · Powder Burns	13	7	7	0.000	6	6	1	12
117	Sword · Age of Winters	10	7	4	-0.273	6	3	1	9
123	Flaming Lips · At War With the Mystics	17	6	13	0.368	4	11	2	15
123	Los Lobos · The Town and the City	17	6	15	0.429	2	11	4	13
123	Morrissey · Ringleader of the Tormentors	14	6	9	0.200	5	8	1	13
123	Streets · The Hardest Way to Make an Easy Living	13	6	10	0.250	3	7	3	10
123	Gossip · Standing in the Way of Control	12	6	9	0.200	3	6	3	9
123	Goldfrapp · Supernature	11	6	7	0.077	4	5	2	9
123	OutKast · IdleWild	11	6	8	0.143	3	5	3	8
123	Celtic Frost · Monotheist	10	6	7	0.077	3	4	3	7
123	Mew · And the Glass Handed Kites	10	6	6	0.000	4	4	2	8
132	James Hunter · People Gonna Talk	14	5	10	0.333	4	9	1	13
132	Alejandro Escovedo · The Boxing Mirror	13	5	11	0.375	2	8	3	10
132	Robyn Hitchcock and the Venus 3 · Ole! Tarantula	13	5	11	0.375	2	8	3	10
132	Josh Ritter · The Animal Years	10	5	9	0.286	1	5	4	6
136	John Legend · Once Again	16	4	15	0.579	1	12	3	13
136	Tom Petty · Highway Companion	13	4	12	0.500	1	9	3	10
136	Long Winters · Putting the Days to Bed	11	4	9	0.385	2	7	2	9
136	Ray Davies · Other People's Lives	11	4	10	0.429	1	7	3	8
136	Paul Simon · Surprise	10	4	7	0.273	3	6	1	9