TWAS 501b: 2004 Pazz & Jop critical alignment ratings

2004 Pazz & Jop critical alignment ratings

501b · 11 February 05

Here are the voters in the 2004 Village Voice Pazz & Jop Critics' Poll, rated according to the average number of other voters who voted for each of their picks. Each voter is assigned one rating for their album ballot, one for their singles ballot in its raw form, and a third for their singles ballot normalized to artists (with the delta between the two singles ratings also shown for the curious). The composite rating weighs the album rating 3/6, the raw singles rating 1/6 and the singles-by-artist rating 2/6, in an attempt to reflect the significance of divergence in addition to the fact of it. Click any heading to see the list sorted by that field.

Versions of this analysis are also available for 2003, 2002, 2001 and 2000.

#	ID	voter	albums	singles raw	singles by artist	(singles delta)	composite
1	1276	Marc Weisblott	105.4	2	7.2	5.2	55.4
2	751	Keith Phipps	104.2
3	820	Chris Molanphy	104.1	47.5	54.4	6.9	78.1
4	3232	David Bratton	103.5	57.5	67.2	9.7	83.7
5	505	Roy Trakin	103	30.2	34.8	4.6	68.1
6	134	Gavin Edwards	102.4
7	4649	Joe D'Angelo	102.1
8	4811	Eric Danton	101.7	91.5	106.1	14.6	101.4
9	1118	Ken Rayes	99.6	21.6	23.7	2.1	61.3
10	165	Michael Gallucci	97.9	49	56.3	7.3	75.8
11	214	Robert Hilburn	96.9	66.6	77.9	11.3	85.5
12	4492	Stephen Mooallem	96.6	48.2	64.8	16.6	77.9
13	4959	Josh Eells	96.3	82.7	94.4	11.7	93.4
14	4848	Saul Austerlitz	96.1	35.6	52.9	17.3	71.6
15	4823	Nate Chinen	95.7	47.8	55.5	7.7	74.3
16	86	Neva Chonin	94.7	63.7	91.3	27.6	88.4
17	146	Jason Fine	94.1	69.7	77.2	7.5	84.4
18	564	Alec Foege	93.4
19	4868	Raymond Fiore	92.9	64.4	75.4	11	82.3
20	131	Daniel Durchholz	92.7	44.4	63.8	19.4	75
21	3130	Nana Brew-Hammond	92.5	13.2	25.2	12	56.8
22	2045	Gina Vivinetto	91.7
23	4615	Michelle Kleinsak	91.6	39.5	48.7	9.2	68.6
24	120	Dan DeLuca	91.4	36.5	44.8	8.3	66.7
25	847	James Tai	91
26	61	Nathan Brackett	90.8	72.2	81.9	9.7	84.7
27	4894	Dorian Lynskey	90.5	37.3	54.9	17.6	69.7
28	4556	Josh Tyrangiel	90.4	47.8	78.4	30.6	79.3
28	537	David Wild	90.4
30	4610	Alison Prato	89.2	51.8	69.2	17.4	76.3
30	543	Chris Willman	89.2	17	21.2	4.2	54.5
32	328	Sia Michel	89	84.7	96	11.3	90.6
33	67	Rob Brunner	88	46.9	59.9	13	71.7
34	658	Al Choman	87.9	68.7	79.1	10.4	81.7
35	4177	Stephen M. Deusner	87.8	40.8	65.9	25.1	72.6
36	894	Joshua Goldfein	87.3	30.7	44.8	14.1	63.7
36	381	Karla Peterson	87.3	37.3	46.4	9.1	65.3
38	187	Gary Graff	87.1	12.1	21.3	9.2	52.6
39	4412	Nick Marino	87	60.6	72.1	11.5	77.6
40	285	Joe Levy	86.6	37.1	67.5	30.4	71.9
41	4776	Derek Paiva	86	60.1	71.3	11.2	76.7
42	4379	Dave Lipp	85.4	63.2	73.4	10.2	77.7
43	90	Gary Chun	84.7	46.7	51.9	5.2	67.4
44	12	Charles Aaron	84	50.3	57.1	6.8	69.4
45	4748	Matt Sebastian	83.7	44.1	70.8	26.7	72.8
46	1184	Marc Spitz	83.3	71.4	85.3	13.9	81.9
47	3009	Max Berry	83.2
47	4587	Josh Love	83.2	30	35	5	58.2
47	4765	Nikhil Swaminathan	83.2	40.1	48	7.9	64.2
50	376	Jon Pareles	83.1
51	2027	Tom Lane	82.8	57.6	65.4	7.8	72.8
51	548	L. Kent Wolgamott	82.8	44.3	56.3	12	67.5
53	339	Tom Moon	82.7	45.8	50.4	4.6	65.7
54	4432	Brian Orloff	82.3	41.6	51	9.4	65
55	3237	Clifford J. Corcoran	82.2	58.5	88.1	29.6	80.2
56	2006	Caryn B. Brooks	80.9	48	71.3	23.3	72.2
57	317	Evelyn McDonnell	80.7
58	3122	Glenn Gamboa	80.6	41.4	53.9	12.5	65.1
59	3014	Steven Chean	80.2	32.6	48.2	15.6	61.6
60	62	Jon Bream	80.1	43.8	58.9	15.1	66.9
60	4779	Chris Neal	80.1	53.3	62	8.7	69.6
62	3055	Jaime Lowe	79.2	14.5	35.8	21.3	53.9
62	4771	Chris Macias	79.2	62	75.8	13.8	75.2
64	274	Greg Kot	78.8	82	97.2	15.2	85.4
65	3017	Timothy Davis	78.7
66	375	Michael Paoletta	78.3	10.6	19	8.4	47.2
67	415	Paul Robicheau	78.2	54.2	67.7	13.5	70.7
68	558	Stephanie Zacharek	77.5
69	333	Greg Milner	76.9
69	696	Stacy Osbaum	76.9
71	3202	Jeff Perlah	76.7	13.7	24.8	11.1	48.9
72	66	David Browne	76.4	50	59.4	9.4	66.3
73	448	Rob Sheffield	76.3	42.7	54.9	12.2	63.5
74	1226	Alex Pappademas	76.2	28.8	37.2	8.4	55.3
75	289	Alan Light	75.6	71.7	86.1	14.4	78.4
76	1223	Ed Condran	75.5	18.9	69.7	50.8	64.1
77	3244	Melissa Maerz	75.4
78	104	Richard Cromelin	74.8
78	3229	Christian Hoard	74.8	42	52.4	10.4	61.8
80	3256	Scott Mervis	74.6	66.6	76	9.4	73.7
80	3084	Amy Phillips	74.6	23.5	30.4	6.9	51.3
82	138	Steve Erickson	74.4	56.2	63.6	7.4	67.7
83	4653	Rodrigo Perez	74.3	0.7	16.7	16	42.8
84	4665	Michael Deeds	74.2	45.6	56.4	10.8	63.5
85	4333	Trevor Kelley	74.1	42	56.2	14.2	62.7
86	4745	Rachel Devitt	73.9	46.2	58.3	12.1	64
87	1116	Joshua Klein	73.8	40.6	58.8	18.2	63.2
88	166	Smith Galtney	73.5	25.2	37.7	12.5	53.5
88	582	John Lewis	73.5
90	467	Franklin Soults	73.1	41.5	51	9.5	60.4
91	4907	David Hughes	73	54	69.1	15.1	68.5
91	522	Barry Walters	73	42.2	48	5.8	59.5
93	1129	Joan Anderman	72.6
94	584	Philip Martin	72.4	39	53.2	14.2	60.4
95	272	Steve Kiviat	72.3	45.4	55.2	9.8	62.1
96	2018	Renee Graham	71.7	63.2	79.4	16.2	72.8
96	363	Chris Norris	71.7
98	882	Ethan Brown	71.6	36.6	41.3	4.7	55.6
98	105	Charles R. Cross	71.6	56.5	65	8.5	66.8
100	3196	Ben Sisario	71.5
101	471	Steven Stancell	71.3
102	4300	J. Edward Keyes	71.2	28.5	31.6	3.1	50.8
103	4958	Jay Lustig	70.9
104	3206	Emily Goldberg	70.8	45.6	69	23.4	66
105	3252	Allison Stewart	70.7	11	15.8	4.8	42.4
106	324	David Menconi	70.6
107	4485	Bob Townsend	70.5	37.6	42	4.4	55.5
108	3118	Pete Glowatsky	70.4	58.5	64.4	5.9	66.4
109	4743	Janna Chan	70.3	66.5	76.6	10.1	71.7
110	972	Larry Katz	69.9
110	619	Dennis Lim	69.9	29.7	43.9	14.2	54.5
112	744	J. Anthony Ware	69.8	35.7	49.1	13.4	57.2
113	568	Richard Martin	69.7	69.7	74.5	4.8	71.3
114	250	Robert Johnson	69.2
115	1262	Steve Knopper	69	22.4	33.9	11.5	49.5
115	4793	Lara Landa	69	64.4	74.3	9.9	70
115	853	Oliver Wang	69	17.2	17.9	0.7	43.3
118	122	Jim DeRogatis	68.8
119	4713	Laurence Station	68.7	33.9	41	7.1	53.6
119	480	James Sullivan	68.7	38	47.4	9.4	56.4
121	4879	Sarah Zupko	68.6
122	3061	Chris Baty	68.2	5.7	9.3	3.6	38.1
122	4764	Michael Endelman	68.2	63.9	73.6	9.7	69.2
124	3178	Troy Brookins	68	42.6	52.4	9.8	58.5
125	221	Bill Holdship	67.3
126	3070	Stephen Thomas Erlewine	67.2	62.1	70.8	8.7	67.5
127	188	Patricia Grandjean	66.7	31.8	40.7	8.9	52.2
128	692	Shane Harrison	66.6	41.6	54.8	13.2	58.5
129	4725	Caryn Ganz	66.5	60.4	65.8	5.4	65.2
130	88	Thor Christensen	66.4
131	553	Ron Wynn	66.3	39.1	46.8	7.7	55.2
132	1268	Chris Herrington	66.2	57.4	64.9	7.5	64.3
133	4729	Ryan Schreiber	66.1	33.1	43.8	10.7	53.1
134	4845	Ross Raihala	65.9	68	81.7	13.7	71.5
135	4628	Michael Tatum	65.7
135	4965	Armond White	65.7	41.3	73.4	32.1	64.2
137	4680	Erich Scholz	65.4	46.7	58.7	12	60
138	3059	Christopher O'Connor	65.3	49.1	61.5	12.4	61.3
139	4434	Chris Baldwin	65
140	4810	Ron Warnick	64.9
141	4564	Jon Moskowitz	64.8	16.8	24.1	7.3	43.2
142	1221	Alec Hanley Bemis	64.6	76.9	82.1	5.2	72.4
143	675	Gaylord Fields	64.5
144	3079	Craig Marks	64.4	43	75.3	32.3	64.4
145	1264	Bobby Reed	64.3	34.2	47.7	13.5	53.7
146	26	Steve Appleford	64.2	65.7	86.7	21	71.9
147	3102	Jon Jon Scott	64.1	39.4	48.3	8.9	54.7
147	4567	Jonathan Stuart	64.1	48	60.6	12.6	60.2
149	362	Tony Norman	64
150	491	Rob Tannenbaum	63.9	42	48.1	6.1	54.9
150	4574	Jim Tremayne	63.9	14.3	27.6	13.3	43.5
150	4539	Mikael Wood	63.9	36.4	42.6	6.2	52.2
153	1210	Sarah Rodman	63.6	27.3	45	17.7	51.3
154	1109	Keith Harris	63.4	26.2	31.7	5.5	46.6
155	3152	Carey Price	63.3	50.3	65	14.7	61.7
156	3294	Jodi Shapiro	63.1	50.8	61	10.2	60.3
157	2021	Danny Hooley	62.9	43.9	49.9	6	55.4
157	1034	Chris Nelson	62.9
157	4939	Alfred Soto	62.9	59.1	82.2	23.1	68.7
160	336	Seth Mnookin	62.8
161	3204	Mark Zepezauer	62.6	34.5	68.9	34.4	60
162	4726	Zac Crain	62.5	74.6	87.1	12.5	72.7
162	4505	Steve May	62.5
164	3193	Josh Modell	62.4	34.8	51.5	16.7	54.1
165	1153	Corey du Browa	62.3	46.4	57.3	10.9	57.9
165	213	Will Hermes	62.3	39.1	56.3	17.2	56.4
167	769	Jenny Eliscu	62.1	56.3	67.7	11.4	63
167	4962	Michael Jarrett	62.1	62.6	72.8	10.2	65.7
169	4918	Rob Mitchum	62	40	47.8	7.8	53.6
169	427	Melissa Ruggieri	62	45.2	54.3	9.1	56.6
171	2007	Michael D. Clark	61.4
171	635	Curtis Ross	61.4	62.6	65	2.4	62.8
171	798	Jay Ruttenberg	61.4	22.9	31.1	8.2	44.8
174	240	Joseph Patel	61	48.1	50.3	2.2	55.2
175	97	Jim Connelly	60.7	33	39.8	6.8	49.1
176	158	David Fricke	60.3	78.6	90	11.4	73.2
177	99	Kevin R. Convey	60.2
178	89	Robert Christgau	60.1	24.5	29.4	4.9	43.9
178	4798	Chris Dahlen	60.1	31.1	51	19.9	52.2
178	4788	Zoe Gemelli	60.1	43.5	51.4	7.9	54.4
181	3218	Lynne Johnson	59.9
182	3243	Sean Howe	59.8	11.1	17.8	6.7	37.6
182	3127	Steve Klinge	59.8	53.5	68.2	14.7	61.5
182	470	P. Gregory Springer	59.8
185	4954	Bill O'Neill	59.5	32.6	44.3	11.7	49.9
186	4201	Mark J. Lepage	59.4	99	112.2	13.2	83.6
187	4193	David John Farinella	59.3
187	4951	Dave Morris	59.3	41.3	46.8	5.5	52.1
187	4730	Eyder Peralta	59.3
190	4942	Sean Fennessey	59.2	45.1	48.7	3.6	53.3
190	4913	David Moore	59.2	38.2	45.8	7.6	51.2
192	4554	Hua Hsu	58.9	16.2	20	3.8	38.8
192	719	Jim Meyer	58.9
194	4925	Rollie Pemberton	58.7	20	24.2	4.2	40.7
194	441	Scott Schinder	58.7
194	846	Jeff Stratton	58.7
197	4358	Thee-O	58.5	10.8	36.3	25.5	43.1
198	3238	Chuck Klosterman	58.4	41.9	51.1	9.2	53.2
199	974	Dave Lindquist	58.3	72.8	89.2	16.4	71
200	279	Michael Lach	58.2	31.9	40.7	8.8	47.9
201	3301	Spencer Kaufman	58.1	52.5	62	9.5	58.4
202	3146	Tim Grierson	57.7	38.7	42.7	4	49.5
202	780	Ron Hart	57.7	47.9	57.8	9.9	56.1
202	579	Steve Horowitz	57.7
202	4617	Alex Mulcahy	57.7
206	4584	Rick Petreycik	57.6	27	32.5	5.5	44.1
207	992	Kevin O'Hare	57.4
208	4877	Zeth Lundy	57.2	7.6	12.3	4.7	33.9
209	142	Jim Farber	56.8	30.8	49.4	18.6	50
210	616	Jonathan Valania	56.6
211	3215	Mike Cimicata	56.5	17.8	36	18.2	43.2
211	157	Sasha Frere-Jones	56.5	50.8	60.1	9.3	56.7
213	597	John McPartlin	56.4	37.4	43.6	6.2	48.9
213	4751	Kevin O'Donnell	56.4	32.8	50.7	17.9	50.5
215	4961	Jesse Fuchs	56.2	9.6	32.3	22.7	40.4
216	4878	Adrien Begrand	56	29	35.3	6.3	44.6
217	2038	Craig Smith	55.7	37.3	54.1	16.8	52.1
218	4948	James Montgomery	55.6	75.4	85	9.6	68.7
219	1211	Hobey Echlin	55.2	8.5	13.3	4.8	33.4
219	334	John Milward	55.2
219	1256	Laura Sinagra	55.2	24.6	29.5	4.9	41.5
219	4650	Jonah Weiner	55.2	55.4	80.7	25.3	63.7
223	3150	Anders Smith Lindall	55.1	41.5	53.1	11.6	52.1
224	606	Timothy Finn	55	36.5	77.6	41.1	59.4
225	3265	Piotr Orlov	54.9	41.7	45.5	3.8	49.5
226	3155	Steve Reynolds	54.8	36.7	49.5	12.8	50
227	3026	Kelefa Sanneh	54.5	48.3	49.5	1.2	51.8
228	3179	Daphne Carr	54.2	31.5	41.2	9.7	46
229	290	Amy Linden	53.9	50.2	55.3	5.1	53.7
230	1083	Michaelangelo Matos	53.7	56.4	60.3	3.9	56.3
231	671	Jon Dolan	53.6	26.5	31.8	5.3	41.8
232	634	Linda Ray	53.5
233	862	Joe Heim	53.3	54.4	66.7	12.3	57.9
233	4732	Dylan Hicks	53.3	23.3	26.6	3.3	39.4
235	4869	Luke Hackney	52.9
236	335	Rick Mitchell	52.8	16.9	28.3	11.4	38.6
236	4595	Brian M. Raftery	52.8	12.4	36.8	24.4	40.7
238	401	Kurt B. Reighley	52.6	43.1	66.1	23	55.5
238	851	Jennifer Vineyard	52.6	15.1	23.1	8	36.5
240	4876	Stephen Haag	52.4	30.8	40	9.2	44.6
240	4655	Tracey Pepper	52.4	44	54.3	10.3	51.6
240	762	Mac Randall	52.4
243	407	Ken Richardson	52.1
244	4496	Daniel Marek	52
245	4720	Marcello Carlin	51.8	3.9	8.1	4.2	29.2
245	2010	Nick Catucci	51.8	35.5	43.5	8	46.3
247	32	Michael Azerrad	51.7	60.3	74.1	13.8	60.6
248	246	Dean Johnson	51.5
249	592	Werner Trieschmann	51.3	15.7	30.2	14.5	38.3
250	3128	Jem Aswad	51.2	59.6	63.5	3.9	56.7
251	489	Jeff Tamarkin	51.1
252	3008	Andrew Bartlett	50.9	14.4	21.3	6.9	34.9
252	709	Toure	50.9
254	4691	Thomas Golianopoulos	50.8	60.3	72.8	12.5	59.7
255	4949	Jason Cherkis	50.6
255	119	Anthony DeCurtis	50.6	12.6	20.9	8.3	34.3
257	4543	Joe Hagan	50.4
257	297	Jim Macnie	50.4
259	661	Rickey Wright	50.2	64.5	75.1	10.6	60.8
260	4558	Josh Davidson	50
261	4929	Raymond Cummings	49.8	27.3	36.6	9.3	41.6
262	648	Bill Friskics-Warren	49.5	42.1	52.1	10	49.1
263	4700	Andy Beta	49.1	63.3	69.1	5.8	58.1
264	636	Rob Michaels	49	57.9	67.2	9.3	56.5
265	617	Carlo Wolff	48.9	30	32.2	2.2	40.1
266	4742	Geeta Dayal	48.7	37.6	39.1	1.5	43.6
266	303	Peter Margasak	48.7
268	3289	Mary Huhn	48.6	15.4	34.3	18.9	38.3
269	216	Geoffrey Himes	48.5	28.8	29.8	1	38.9
270	4851	Constantine Caloudas	48.1	8.1	9.7	1.6	28.6
271	113	Cary Darling	48
272	861	Meredith Ochs	47.4
273	998	Alex Ross	47.3	22.7	36.9	14.2	39.7
274	4884	Jesse Fox Mayshark	47.2	39.2	45.3	6.1	45.2
275	3090	Dan Strachota	47	14.3	17.3	3	31.6
276