furia furialog · New Particles · The War Against Silence · Aedliga (songs) · photography · code · other things     ↑vF
2006 Pazz & Jop critical alignment ratings
Here are the voters in the 2006 Village Voice Pazz & Jop critics poll, rated according to the number of voters who voted for each of their album picks. The maximum possible score according to my tabulation was 747. The minimum score for a full 10-vote ballot was, obviously, 10.
Versions of this analysis are also available for the 2005, 2004, 2003, 2002, 2001 and 2000 Pazz & Jop polls, and the 2006 Jackin' Pop poll.
(Next up, an attempt to merge the polls.)
# Voter Votes Rating Average Ballot
1Charles Aaron 10 597 59.7 12
2Scott Crawford 10 560 56.0 5103
3Paul Robicheau 10 546 54.6 415
4Robert Hilburn 10 533 53.3 214
5Chris Nelson 10 527 52.7 1034
6Max Berry 10 514 51.4 3009
7David Menconi 10 504 50.4 324
8Josh Tyrangiel 10 499 49.9 4556
9Christopher Hickman 10 498 49.8 5016
10Jeff Vrabel 10 497 49.7 5069
11Scott Mervis 10 495 49.5 3256
12Michael Gallucci 10 490 49.0 165
12Dave Gil de Rubio 10 490 49.0 4511
12Laurence Station 10 490 49.0 4713
15Steve Klinge 10 487 48.7 3127
16Corey du Browa 10 481 48.1 1153
16Mark Zepezauer 10 481 48.1 3204
18Andrew Bartlett 10 480 48.0 3008
18Robin A. Rothman 10 480 48.0 1120
20Jack Buehrer 10 476 47.6 4979
21Melissa Maerz 10 469 46.9 3244
22Bret Gladstone 10 459 45.9 5162
23Theon Weber 10 458 45.8 5161
24J. Anthony Ware 10 457 45.7 744
25Eric Danton 10 443 44.3 4811
26Franklin Soults 10 439 43.9 467
27Philip Martin 10 438 43.8 584
28Michelle Brunner 10 435 43.5 4615
28Ben Wener 10 435 43.5 660
30Shane Harrison 10 433 43.3 692
31Ryan Dombal 10 424 42.4 5043
32Jay Ruttenberg 10 423 42.3 798
33Charles R. Cross 10 422 42.2 105
33Chris Herrington 10 422 42.2 1268
35Will Hermes 10 419 41.9 213
35Christine Richmond 10 419 41.9 5029
37Ben Sisario 10 417 41.7 3196
38Jon Bream 10 416 41.6 62
39Al Choman 10 415 41.5 658
40Dave Lipp 10 411 41.1 4379
40David Marchese 10 411 41.1 5006
42Miles Marshall Lewis 10 408 40.8 286
43Dan DeLuca 10 406 40.6 120
43A.S. Van Dorston 10 406 40.6 4602
45Saul Austerlitz 10 405 40.5 4848
46Erik Kenward 10 403 40.3 4932
47Greg Kot 10 398 39.8 274
48Ken Rayes 10 396 39.6 1118
49Kristal Hawkins 10 394 39.4 4950
50Jon Matsumoto 10 389 38.9 312
50Milo Miles 10 389 38.9 329
52Josh Eells 10 388 38.8 4959
53Derek Miller 10 386 38.6 4971
54Dave Herrera 10 385 38.5 5143
55Mikael Wood 10 382 38.2 4539
56Allison Stewart 10 380 38.0 3252
57Joshua Alston 10 379 37.9 5165
57Dan Reines 10 379 37.9 3281
59Rachel Devitt 10 377 37.7 4745
60Justin Cober-Lake 10 375 37.5 4972
60Michael Deeds 10 375 37.5 4665
60Luke Hackney 10 375 37.5 4869
63Bill O'Neill 10 374 37.4 4954
64Tim Grierson 10 370 37.0 3146
65Rossiter Drake 10 368 36.8 5171
65Curtis Ross 10 368 36.8 635
65L. Kent Wolgamott 10 368 36.8 548
68Jim Connelly 10 365 36.5 97
69Sean Fennessey 10 361 36.1 4942
69Sam Ubl 10 361 36.1 4915
71Michael Lach 10 360 36.0 279
72Tom Lane 10 359 35.9 2027
73Britt Robson 10 357 35.7 416
74Josh du Lac 10 355 35.5 5073
75Whitney Pastorek 10 354 35.4 4896
76Ted Cox 10 352 35.2 102
76Anders Smith Lindall 10 352 35.2 3150
78Amy Linden 7 245 35.0 290
79Randall Roberts 10 349 34.9 412
80David Fricke 10 348 34.8 158
80Steve Horowitz 10 348 34.8 579
82Andrew Gaerig 10 346 34.6 5119
82Jonah Weiner 10 346 34.6 4650
84Steve Simels 10 340 34.0 453
85Tom Breihan 10 338 33.8 5000
85Phil Gallo 10 338 33.8 164
85Amanda Petrusich 10 338 33.8 4663
88Kyle Anderson 10 337 33.7 5099
88Brian Orloff 10 337 33.7 4432
90Andy Gensler 10 335 33.5 4722
91Stephen M. Deusner 10 334 33.4 4177
92Ed Condran 10 333 33.3 1223
92Aaron Richter 10 333 33.3 4998
94Marc Hogan 10 332 33.2 5088
95Gary Graff 10 329 32.9 187
95Robert Morast 10 329 32.9 5154
97Marisa Brown 10 327 32.7 5156
97Nate Cavalieri 10 327 32.7 3106
97Steve Erickson 10 327 32.7 138
97Steve Knopper 10 327 32.7 1262
101Clifford J. Corcoran 10 325 32.5 3237
102Mike Powell 10 324 32.4 5127
102Ross Raihala 10 324 32.4 4845
104Chris Baldwin 10 321 32.1 4434
104Kevin Lo 10 321 32.1 5093
106Caryn B. Brooks 10 319 31.9 2006
106Adam Miller 10 319 31.9 4297
106Jim Tremayne 10 319 31.9 4574
109Robert Christgau 10 316 31.6 89
109J. Edward Keyes 10 316 31.6 4300
109Shannon Zimmerman 10 316 31.6 3276
112Ken Capobianco 10 315 31.5 73
112Daniel Durchholz 10 315 31.5 131
114Gary Chun 10 314 31.4 90
115Kevin O'Donnell 10 313 31.3 4751
116Alfred Soto 10 312 31.2 4939
117Robert Loerzel 10 311 31.1 4964
118Jon Jon Scott 10 310 31.0 3102
119Kembrew McLeod 10 309 30.9 595
120Zach Baron 10 306 30.6 5097
121Michael Ayers 10 305 30.5 5007
121John Davidson 10 305 30.5 5159
123Amy Schroeder 10 302 30.2 4623
123Matt Sebastian 10 302 30.2 4748
125Chris Riemenschneider 10 301 30.1 989
126Caryn Ganz 10 299 29.9 4725
126Scott Plagenhoef 10 299 29.9 4696
126Nick Sylvester 10 299 29.9 4904
129Matthew Perpetua 10 297 29.7 4931
129David Wild 10 297 29.7 537
131Rob Dubbin 10 296 29.6 4910
131Michael Endelman 10 296 29.6 4764
133Austin L. Ray 10 295 29.5 4997
134Bobby Reed 10 294 29.4 1264
135Thor Christensen 10 293 29.3 88
135Will Spitz 10 293 29.3 5080
137A.D. Amorosi 10 292 29.2 1181
137Josh Love 10 292 29.2 4587
139Barry Walters 10 291 29.1 522
140Jesse Fox Mayshark 10 290 29.0 4884
141Mallory O'Donnell 10 289 28.9 5121
142Steve Baltin 10 288 28.8 4987
142Ken Tucker 10 288 28.8 506
144Michael Hoinski 10 285 28.5 4936
145Andy Beta 10 284 28.4 4700
146Richard Gehr 10 283 28.3 171
147Spencer Patterson 10 282 28.2 5070
148Jessica Grose 10 281 28.1 4940
149Zeth Lundy 10 280 28.0 4877
150Bob Grossweiner 10 277 27.7 195
151Steve Pick 10 276 27.6 385
151James Rodgers 10 276 27.6 4799
153Mark Pytlik 10 273 27.3 4568
154Brett Sokol 10 270 27.0 1270
155Eric T. Miller 10 269 26.9 612
156Richard Abowitz 10 268 26.8 680
156Scott Holter 10 268 26.8 4535
158Jonathan Bradley 10 267 26.7 5120
159Steve Forstneger 10 266 26.6 4734
159Mark Richardson 10 266 26.6 4968
161David Downs 10 263 26.3 5128
162Adam Moerder 10 262 26.2 4945
163Mac Randall 10 259 25.9 762
164Alvin Aqua Boogie Blanco 10 258 25.8 4859
164Jessica Koslow 10 258 25.8 4906
164David Shirley 10 258 25.8 450
167Adrien Begrand 10 257 25.7 4878
167Carla DeSantis 10 257 25.7 3066
167Rob Harvilla 10 257 25.7 3284
167Andy Kellman 10 257 25.7 4571
171Eric Elbogen 10 256 25.6 4825
171Stephen Thomas Erlewine 10 256 25.6 3070
173Nick Green 10 255 25.5 4953
174Jason Cherkis 10 254 25.4 4949
174Jon Young 10 254 25.4 556
176Lee Stabert 10 251 25.1 5138
177Craig Smith 10 250 25.0 2038
178Thomas Inskeep 10 249 24.9 4718
178Noel Murray 10 249 24.9 1117
178Jaan Uhelszki 10 249 24.9 510
181Ed Masley 10 248 24.8 1028
182Sarah Rodman 10 247 24.7 1210
183Brett Koshkin 10 246 24.6 5141
184Larry King 10 245 24.5 823
185Makkada B. Selah 10 243 24.3 5031
186Chris Neal 10 242 24.2 4779
186Derek Paiva 10 242 24.2 4776
188Matt Diehl 10 241 24.1 127
188Nikhil Swaminathan 10 241 24.1 4765
190John Kenyon 10 240 24.0 4780
191Christian Schaeffer 10 238 23.8 5142
192Eskay 10 237 23.7 5123
192Kevin O'Hare 10 237 23.7 992
194Andrew Nosnitsky 10 236 23.6 5124
195Charles Johnson 10 235 23.5 244
195Jessica Robertson 10 235 23.5 5077
195Scott Wilson 10 235 23.5 3270
195Douglas Wolk 10 235 23.5 549
199Andy Dubbin 10 234 23.4 5060
200Mosi Reeves 10 233 23.3 2034
200Jim Testa 10 233 23.3 500
202Phillip Overeem 10 232 23.2 1260
202Rick Petreycik 10 232 23.2 4584
204Jem Aswad 10 231 23.1 3128
205Holly George-Warren 10 230 23.0 173
206John Milward 10 229 22.9 334
206Ben Westhoff 10 229 22.9 5147
208Kevin Moreau 10 228 22.8 4714
208Ken Richardson 10 228 22.8 407
210Bill Holdship 10 226 22.6 221
211Jeanne Fury 10 225 22.5 4425
212Brian Howe 10 224 22.4 4920
212Chairman Jefferson Mao 10 224 22.4 300
214Cristina Black 10 223 22.3 5098
215Rachel Leibrock 10 221 22.1 611
215Brian O'Neill 10 221 22.1 4619
215Allen St. John 10 221 22.1 432
218Billy Altman 10 219 21.9 19
218Bud Scoppa 10 219 21.9 444
218Toure 10 219 21.9 709
221Jeff Jackson 10 217 21.7 1038
221Kevin John 10 217 21.7 1030
223Andy Wang 10 215 21.5 4632
224K. Leander Williams 10 214 21.4 877
225Parke Puterbaugh 10 213 21.3 396
225Carlo Wolff 10 213 21.3 617
227Rob O'Connor 10 212 21.2 364
228Sherman Johnson 10 210 21.0 4659
229Doug Brod 10 208 20.8 3176
229Rebecca Raber 10 208 20.8 5160
231James Montgomery 10 206 20.6 4948
232Mike Cimicata 10 205 20.5 3215
232Steve Reynolds 10 205 20.5 3155
234Jason Killingsworth 10 204 20.4 4938
235Steve Smith 10 203 20.3 4487
236Kara Manning 10 202 20.2 929
236Andrew Parks 10 202 20.2 4870
238Ron Hart 10 201 20.1 780
239Simon Reynolds 10 200 20.0 405
240Anthony DeCurtis 10 199 19.9 119
240Michael Nelson 10 199 19.9 3250
242Mike Berick 10 198 19.8 3266
242Steve Hochman 10 198 19.8 219
244Nicole Elyse 10 196 19.6 4560
245Jon Caramanica 10 195 19.5 1134
246Greg Beets 10 194 19.4 727
246Steve Kiviat 10 194 19.4 272
248Tom Hull 9 174 19.333 4627
249Christopher R. Weingarten 10 193 19.3 4775
250Howard Cohen 10 192 19.2 915
250John Seroff 10 192 19.2 5032
252D. Strauss 10 191 19.1 739
253Ryan Smith 10 190 19.0 4708
254Cortney Harding 10 189 18.9 5015
254Ira Robbins 10 189 18.9 411
256Josh Langhoff 10 188 18.8 4928
257Stephen Haag 10 187 18.7 4876
257Jon Wiederhorn 10 187 18.7 536
259Lissa Townsend Rodgers 10 185 18.5 417
260Daniel DiMaggio 10 184 18.4 4599
260Cameron MacDonald 10 184 18.4 4917
260Ken Micallef 10 184 18.4 1086
260Derk Richardson 10 184 18.4 406
264Trent Fitzgerald 10 183 18.3 667
264Jeff Tamarkin 10 183 18.3 489
266Brian Bowe 10 182 18.2 4864
266Bob Ruggiero 10 182 18.2 428
266Lloyd Sachs 10 182 18.2 4464
269Matt Ryan 10 180 18.0 1151
269Werner Trieschmann 10 180 18.0 592
271Brian Smith 10 179 17.9 4545
271David Sprague 10 179 17.9 469
273Jason Gross 10 178 17.8 895
273Jason Harper 10 178 17.8 5131
273Mike Mettler 10 178 17.8 2030
276Matthew Fritch 10 177 17.7 784
276Ron Mashate 10 177 17.7 5164
276Rob Michaels 10 177 17.7 636
279Jill Ettinger 10 175 17.5 4801
279Maura Johnston 10 175 17.5 4634
281Mike Pelusi 10 174 17.4 4767
281Melissa Ruggieri 10 174 17.4 427
283Andrew Harrison 10 173 17.3 5052
283Kenny Herzog 10 173 17.3 4999
285Jonathan Stuart 10 172 17.2 4567
286Dan Ouellette 10 171 17.1 369
287K. Ross Hoffman 10 170 17.0 4947
287Fred Mills 10 170 17.0 332
289Todd Kristel 10 169 16.9 3148
290Jer Fairall 10 167 16.7 4786
290Curtis Schieber 10 167 16.7 588
292Peter Scholtes 10 166 16.6 1246
292Aidin Vaziri 10 166 16.6 573
294Jay Lustig 10 164 16.4 4958
294Grant Moser 10 164 16.4 4728
296Evelyn McDonnell 10 163 16.3 317
297Marc Hirsch 8 130 16.25 4857
298Dev Sherlock 10 161 16.1 632
299Sarah Zupko 10 160 16.0 4879
300Susan Moll 10 159 15.9 3246
300Andrew Strickman 10 159 15.9 4519
302John Bush 10 158 15.8 4754
303Emily Goldberg 10 157 15.7 3206
304Brian Block 10 156 15.6 4769
304Catherine Lewis 10 156 15.6 514
304Thomas May 10 156 15.6 3005
307Colin Fleming 10 155 15.5 5010
308Anthony Easton 10 154 15.4 5074
309Tara Henley 10 152 15.2 5036
309Jesse Jarnow 10 152 15.2 4895
309Darrell M. McNeill 10 152 15.2 323
312Sam Hunt 10 149 14.9 4577
313Brian Barr 10 148 14.8 5151
313Tim Pratt 10 148 14.8 3271
315Kandia Crazy Horse 10 147 14.7 891
315James Hunter 10 147 14.7 230
315Chris M. Junior 10 147 14.7 3143
318Kenyon Hopkin 10 146 14.6 3210
319Michael Azerrad 10 143 14.3 32
319Andrew Miller 10 143 14.3 4642
319Josh Timmermann 10 143 14.3 5001
322John Elsasser 10 142 14.2 1155
322George A. Paul 10 142 14.2 4736
322Jack Rabid 10 142 14.2 398
322Leah Weathersby 10 142 14.2 5105
326Mark Jenkins 10 141 14.1 241
327Lee Froehlich 10 139 13.9 4613
327Ellis Widner 10 139 13.9 1222
329Nate Seltenrich 10 137 13.7 5155
330Josh Baron 10 136 13.6 5169
330Jason Cohen 10 136 13.6 92
332Lola Emanuelli 10 134 13.4 4626
332Dan Ferguson 10 134 13.4 1229
334James Bradley 10 133 13.3 5038
334Jimmy Draper 10 133 13.3 3170
336Jason Budjinski 10 132 13.2 5153
336MacKenzie Wilson 10 132 13.2 5157
338Jason Adams 10 130 13.0 4778
339Rich Bienstock 10 129 12.9 5170
339Michael Curtin 10 129 12.9 108
339Otis Hart 10 129 12.9 4580
339Mike Rubin 10 129 12.9 425
343Josh Modell 10 128 12.8 3193
343Scott Schinder 10 128 12.8 441
345Diego Hadis 10 127 12.7 3129
345Pat Pierson 10 127 12.7 4510
347Jennifer Maerz 10 126 12.6 4796
348Eryc Eyl 10 125 12.5 5146
348Matt Hickey 10 125 12.5 1207
350Michael Barthel 10 124 12.4 4733
350Ron Warnick 10 124 12.4 4810
352Dan LeRoy 10 123 12.3 5026
353Joseph McCombs 10 122 12.2 4707
354Dominic Salerno 10 120 12.0 434
354Rob Trucks 10 120 12.0 5166
354Steven Ward 10 120 12.0 3166
357Jason King 10 119 11.9 4667
358James Blount 10 118 11.8 566
358Justin Chun 10 118 11.8 5090
358John Dugan 10 118 11.8 5096
358Doug Levy 10 118 11.8 5059
362Dan Strachota 10 117 11.7 3090
363Bill Holmes 10 116 11.6 1236
363Heather Phares 10 116 11.6 4755
365Joshua Mann 10 112 11.2 5114
366John Everhart 10 111 11.1 4760
366Daniel King 10 111 11.1 4596
368Michael Crumsho 10 109 10.9 5057
369Joseph Robinson 10 107 10.7 3283
370Jim Bessman 10 106 10.6 45
370Holly Gleason 10 106 10.6 177
370Jennifer Kelly 10 106 10.6 4977
373Paul-Emile Comeau 10 104 10.4 1169
373Debbie Guirand 10 104 10.4 4502
373Marianne Meyer 10 104 10.4 327
373Michael Point 10 104 10.4 388
377Jim Meyer 10 103 10.3 719
377Kurt Orzeck 10 103 10.3 4980
379Enrique Lavin 10 102 10.2 3149
380Bob Mehr 10 101 10.1 4533
381Wayne Bledsoe 10 99 9.9 910
381Tom Cheyney 10 99 9.9 85
383Jalylah Burrell 10 97 9.7 5005
383Michael Alan Goldberg 10 97 9.7 3123
385Andy Battaglia 10 96 9.6 3230
385Tracy Moore 10 96 9.6 5137
387Spence D. 10 94 9.4 109
387Doug Mosurak 10 94 9.4 5028
387Bobby Tanzilo 10 94 9.4 492
390Edd Hurt 10 93 9.3 4935
391Steve Matteo 10 92 9.2 313
392Sal Cinquemani 10 91 9.1 4899
393Tom Semioli 10 90 9.0 4493
394John Walker 10 89 8.9 1036
395David Adler 10 88 8.8 1227
395Mike Greenhaus 10 88 8.8 5158
395Joe Tangari 10 88 8.8 4919
398Jason Buhrmester 10 87 8.7 4611
398Joel Calahan 10 87 8.7 4946
398Dominique Leone 10 87 8.7 4699
398Janet Tzou 10 87 8.7 4774
402Chuck Campbell 10 85 8.5 906
402Robert Nedelkoff 10 85 8.5 352
402Ken Scrudato 10 85 8.5 3184
402Tim Ellison 8 68 8.5 3019
406Ken Taylor 10 83 8.3 4766
407Franklin Paul 7 58 8.286 1089
408Jud Cost 10 80 8.0 575
409Pamela Murray Winters 10 79 7.9 3003
410Michael Krugman 10 78 7.8 581
411Craig D. Lindsey 10 77 7.7 5027
411David Moore 10 77 7.7 4913
411Annie Zaleski 10 77 7.7 3279
414Stephen Thompson 10 76 7.6 2042
415Ashlea Halpern 10 75 7.5 4605
415Ken Shimamoto 10 75 7.5 3191
417Baz Dreisinger 9 64 7.111 4542
418M.J. Fine 10 70 7.0 4621
418Marc Masters 10 70 7.0 304
420Tracy Hopkins 10 69 6.9 4831
420Elisabeth Vincentelli 10 69 6.9 516
422Geeta Dayal 9 59 6.556 4742
423Raymond Cummings 10 65 6.5 4929
424Barry Bruner 10 64 6.4 5091
425J. Niimi 10 63 6.3 4781
426Peter Davis 10 62 6.2 3016
427J.D. Considine 10 61 6.1 98
428Jason MacNeil 10 60 6.0 4875
428Glenn McDonald 10 60 6.0 3047
430Philip Booth 10 58 5.8 5163
430Shawn Bosler 10 58 5.8 4182
432Dave DiMartino 10 57 5.7 129
433James J. Jung 10 56 5.6 5024
433Andrew Nash 10 56 5.6 833
435Dan Epstein 10 55 5.5 674
435Ben Lukoff 10 55 5.5 5106
435Ken Switzer 10 55 5.5 4657
438Liz Riley 10 53 5.3 4782
439Dave Clifford 10 51 5.1 3298
439Jodi Shapiro 10 51 5.1 3294
441Dana Bos 10 50 5.0 4783
441Banning Eyre 10 50 5.0 141
441Phil Freeman 10 50 5.0 4168
441Gene Seymour 10 50 5.0 4757
445Frank Kogan 10 49 4.9 645
445Jason Pettigrew 10 49 4.9 4516
447Larry Blumenfeld 10 48 4.8 4802
448Anthony Mariani 7 32 4.571 4206
449Trevor Fisher 10 45 4.5 5076
450Niki D'Andrea 10 44 4.4 5139
450Eugene Jr. Holley 10 44 4.4 222
452J Neo Marvin 10 42 4.2 2028
453Robin James 10 40 4.0 4709
453John Lomax 10 40 4.0 4941
455Adam Bregman 10 34 3.4 888
455Chad Radford 10 34 3.4 5095
455Dave Segal 10 34 3.4 3182
455Tim Sendra 10 34 3.4 4756
459Ethan Covey 10 33 3.3 4576
459Marc Weidenbaum 10 33 3.3 3188
461Brian Turner 10 32 3.2 4902
461Philip Van Vleck 10 32 3.2 4854
461Jon Whitney 10 32 3.2 4557
464Larry Birnbaum 10 31 3.1 48
465Alex Henderson 10 30 3.0 211
466Nathan Birk 10 29 2.9 4513
466Glenn Dixon 10 29 2.9 3018
468Will Romano 10 28 2.8 757
469Bryan Reesman 10 27 2.7 3274
470George Smith 10 25 2.5 461
471Carol Cooper 10 24 2.4 100
472Tom Ewing 3 7 2.333 3240
473Todd Burns 10 23 2.3 4701
474Michael Ross 10 21 2.1 646
475Derek Beres 10 19 1.9 3171
475Ernesto Lechner 10 19 1.9 4861
475Jeffrey Morgan 10 19 1.9 4747
478Viva Las Vegas 5 9 1.8 3285
479Eric Arnold 10 17 1.7 5149
479Cecile Cloutier 10 17 1.7 3235
481Jess Harvell 10 15 1.5 4586
481Anthony Miccio 2 3 1.5 3189
483Robert Kaye 10 14 1.4 4803
483Ken Roseman 10 14 1.4 422
485J. R. Taylor 10 13 1.3 496
486Don Allred 10 12 1.2 1212
486Sterling Clover 10 12 1.2 4548
488Stacy Meyn 10 11 1.1 1162
489David Cotner 10 10 1.0 5013
489Kerry Dexter 10 10 1.0 3220
489Jordan Mamone 10 10 1.0 776
489David Royko 10 10 1.0 778
489Phil Dellio 3 3 1.0 734
Site contents published by glenn mcdonald under a Creative Commons BY/NC/ND License except where otherwise noted.